Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardMain Idea and Primary Purpose

For decades, historians of science attributed the rapid adoption of early nineteenth-century electrochemical theory primarily to its practical utility in isolating novel metallic elements. According to this prevailing narrative, Humphry Davy’s successful isolation of sodium and potassium provided incontrovertible empirical proof that silenced theoretical dissenters. However, recent archival evidence suggests that this technological triumph was actually secondary to a broader conceptual shift. Davy’s contemporaries were not merely swayed by laboratory demonstrations; rather, their enthusiasm was catalyzed by Jöns Jacob Berzelius’s formulation of a dualistic model of chemical affinity that integrated electricity into the foundational ontology of matter. While Davy’s work offered striking empirical phenomena, Berzelius supplied the missing systematic rationale that reconciled dualism with existing Newtonian mechanical principles. By framing chemical bonding through electrostatic attraction, Berzelius allowed chemists to subsume disparate chemical phenomena under a unified physical law. Thus, the triumph of early electrochemistry resulted less from spectacular laboratory achievements than from a sophisticated theoretical synthesis that satisfied the nineteenth-century scientific community's demand for overarching explanatory frameworks.

Which of the following best states the primary purpose of the passage?

  1. challenge a traditional explanation for the adoption of a scientific theory by emphasizing the importance of a theoretical synthesisAnswer
  2. B
    detail the specific laboratory procedures used by early nineteenth-century chemists to isolate novel metallic elements
  3. C
    assert that empirical demonstrations were entirely irrelevant to the scientific community's acceptance of electrochemistry
  4. D
    prove that Berzelius’s dualistic model completely superseded Newtonian mechanical principles in nineteenth-century physics
  5. E
    condemn earlier historians of science for deliberately falsifying the historical record regarding Davy's discoveries

Answer

challenge a traditional explanation for the adoption of a scientific theory by emphasizing the importance of a theoretical synthesis
The passage opens by summarizing a traditional historical narrative focused on Humphry Davy's empirical laboratory accomplishments. It then pivots using the signal word 'However' to present the author's main argument: that the adoption of electrochemistry was primarily driven by Berzelius's theoretical synthesis. Therefore, the primary purpose is to challenge the traditional historical explanation by emphasizing the role of that theoretical conceptual framework.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the passage structural pivot signaling the author's central thesis.
The author outlines a traditional historical view regarding Davy's empirical work and then uses the structural signal word 'However' to present a competing claim about Berzelius's conceptual shift.
Locating structural transitions distinguishes background context from the author's main primary argument.
2
Evaluate how the author supports their primary claim throughout the body paragraph.
The passage details how Berzelius provided an overarching theoretical framework that reconciled dualism with Newtonian principles, which the author concludes was the decisive factor for adoption.
Analyzing the development of the argument confirms that the emphasis rests on the theoretical synthesis rather than laboratory experimentation.
3
Select the option that reflects the comprehensive purpose of re-evaluating the historical narrative.
The statement stating the intention to challenge a traditional explanation through theoretical synthesis precisely encompasses the passage's primary purpose.
The correct main idea response must encompass the full scope and intent of the passage without narrowing onto specific supporting details or making extreme claims.

Key Concept

Identifying the author's primary purpose and main idea in Reading Comprehension passages by evaluating rhetorical structure and main thesis shifts.
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Main Idea and Primary Purpose

More questions from this topic