Question

Difficulty: HardRhetorical Structure and Sentence Function

In the mid-nineteenth century, uniformitarian geology, championed by Charles Lyell, held that erratic boulders and scoured bedrock across Northern Europe were deposited by iceberg drift during a period of submerged continents. Lyell favored this "drift theory" primarily because it preserved his core postulate of gradual, steady-state geological change without invoking catastrophic events. However, when Louis Agassiz proposed in 1840 that expansive continental ice sheets had swept over the land, the scientific community initially dismissed his glacial theory as an unnecessary resurgence of catastrophism. To overcome this resistance, Agassiz pointed to contemporary Alpine glaciers, demonstrating that subglacial abrasion produces distinctive linear striations and unsorted till identical to the features observed across lowland Europe. By anchoring his argument in observable present-day processes, Agassiz skillfully turned uniformitarian logic back against Lyell's supporters. Nonetheless, the drift theory persisted for decades, largely because accepting Agassiz's paradigm required geologists to concede that global temperatures had dropped precipitously in the recent past—a climate anomaly that contemporary thermodynamic theories could not readily explain.

Which of the following best describes the rhetorical function of the sentence "By anchoring his argument in observable present-day processes, Agassiz skillfully turned uniformitarian logic back against Lyell's supporters" in the context of the passage as a whole?

  1. It explains how Agassiz appropriated the foundational methodological principle of his intellectual opponents to validate his own competing hypothesis.Answer
  2. B
    It presents the definitive empirical evidence that brought about the immediate collapse of the drift theory among European geologists.
  3. C
    It introduces a concession in which Agassiz acknowledged a major theoretical limitation of his own glacial paradigm.
  4. D
    It demonstrates that uniformitarian geologists formally abandoned Lyell's postulate of gradual, steady-state change.
  5. E
    It reprimands nineteenth-century scientists for their dogmatic refusal to examine modern geological phenomena.

Answer

It explains how Agassiz appropriated the foundational methodological principle of his intellectual opponents to validate his own competing hypothesis.
The sentence describes how Agassiz strategically adopted the central tenets of uniformitarianism—using observable present-day processes (Alpine glaciers)—to advance his own glacial theory against Lyell's supporters, effectively employing his opponents' methodological framework against them.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the structural role and context of the target sentence.
The target sentence comes immediately after the passage describes Agassiz using contemporary Alpine glaciers (present-day processes) to explain lowland European geological features.
Understanding what precedes the target sentence establishes what 'observable present-day processes' refers to.
2
Connect the target sentence to the core principles of Lyell's supporters mentioned earlier.
Lyell's uniformitarianism relies on explaining geological history through observable, ongoing natural processes. Agassiz used this exact uniformitarian logic (observing active Alpine glaciers) to support his own glacial sheet hypothesis.
Evaluating how Agassiz turned their logic back against them reveals the main rhetorical purpose: using the opponents' own methodology against them.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the statement that accurately reflects this strategic rhetorical function.
The statement asserting that Agassiz appropriated the foundational methodological principle of his intellectual opponents accurately captures the rhetorical function.
It captures both the methodology used (uniformitarian present-day observation) and its application to competing theories.

Key Concept

Rhetorical Structure and Sentence Function
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question