Question

Difficulty: Very hardRhetorical Structure and Sentence Function

Historians of technology have long debated the efficacy of the Venetian Republic’s late fifteenth-century statutes regulating artisan secrecy, particularly regarding the export of cristallo glass formulas. Traditional scholarship posited that the Council of Ten’s punitive decrees established a near-hermetic containment of proprietary technique, thereby sustaining Murano’s commercial monopoly. However, recent archival analyses of economic migration into the Ottoman Levant reveal a far more porous regime. Documented instances of clandestine artisan emigration demonstrate that legal prohibitions functioned less as an absolute barrier to knowledge transfer than as a mechanism for inflating the transaction costs of intellectual capital. By systematically prosecuting defectors while simultaneously granting lucrative monopolistic patents to loyal master craftsmen, Venetian authorities effectively altered the risk-reward calculus of defecting. Consequently, while the unauthorized dissemination of glassmaking technology was not halted entirely, its rate of outward diffusion was sufficiently throttled to preserve Venice's competitive premium for over two centuries.

Based on the passage, which of the following statements correctly describe the rhetorical function of specific sentences or phrases within the passage? Select all that apply.

  1. The sentence beginning with 'Traditional scholarship posited...' introduces an established historiographical consensus that the author subsequently re-evaluates using new archival evidence.Answer
  2. The phrase 'functioning less as an absolute barrier to knowledge transfer than as a mechanism for inflating the transaction costs of intellectual capital' serves to refine the conceptual understanding of how Venetian legal prohibitions operated rather than denying their impact entirely.Answer
  3. C
    The mention of the Council of Ten's punitive decrees is introduced primarily to provide empirical support for the author's main argument that Venetian regulatory measures were completely ineffective.
  4. D
    The final sentence serves to concede that Venetian economic dominance collapsed rapidly due to unthrottled technology dissemination.
  5. E
    The reference to lucrative monopolistic patents functions as a counterargument intended to invalidate the claim that Venetian authorities prosecuted defectors.

Answer

The correct statements are the statement noting that 'Traditional scholarship posited...' introduces an established consensus re-evaluated via new archival evidence, and the statement noting that the phrase regarding transaction costs refines the conceptual understanding of how prohibitions operated.
The statement describing the sentence beginning with 'Traditional scholarship posited...' is correct because that sentence sets up the baseline historical view that the author's subsequent discussion of recent Ottoman Levant archival findings reframes. The statement concerning the phrase about 'inflating the transaction costs of intellectual capital' is correct because the 'less X than Y' structure qualifies the nature of the legal barrier, explaining that it acted as an economic disincentive rather than a total physical containment.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the structural role of the second sentence ('Traditional scholarship posited...')
It outlines the historical baseline view regarding Murano's monopoly, which the word 'However' in sentence 3 subsequently challenges with new Ottoman Levant archival evidence.
Establishing a traditional view before refuting or qualifying it is a standard rhetorical pattern in academic prose.
2
Evaluate the rhetorical role of the comparative clause regarding 'transaction costs of intellectual capital'
The clause shifts the conceptual framing from an 'absolute barrier' to an economic throttling mechanism ('inflating transaction costs'), thus refining rather than dismissing the regulation's function.
Rhetorical function questions require identifying how nuanced qualifications modify the broader argument.
3
Evaluate the remaining choices against passage details to identify misidentifications or scope errors
The claims of 'complete ineffectiveness', 'rapid collapse', and 'counterargument invalidation' contradict the text's explicit synthesis that Venetian policy successfully throttled diffusion to preserve a competitive premium for over two centuries.
Distractors in GRE rhetorical structure questions frequently exaggerate claims into extreme or inverted positions.

Key Concept

Rhetorical Structure and Sentence Function
Rate this question