Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumUnfair Claims Settlement Practices

A surgeon suffers a severe hand injury and files a claim under their individual disability income policy. The insured provides complete medical records and the required physician's statement proving total disability. The insurance company's own medical examiner reviews the file and definitively confirms the surgeon is completely disabled and eligible for full benefits. Despite this clear determination of liability, the insurer intentionally withholds the benefit payments for six months. The insurer's internal notes reveal a strategy to create financial desperation, hoping the surgeon will accept a drastically reduced lump-sum buyout instead of the ongoing monthly benefits they are legally entitled to.

Which of the following statements best describes the regulatory nature of the insurer's strategy according to Unfair Claims Settlement Practices laws?

  1. The insurer is committing a regulatory violation by failing to make a good faith effort to promptly and fairly settle a claim where liability is undisputed.Answer
  2. B
    The strategy is legally acceptable as long as the insurer ultimately pays the delayed benefits with statutory interest added to the final amount.
  3. C
    The insurer's conduct is classified as a valid competitive business practice designed to protect the company's financial reserves from excessive claim payouts.
  4. D
    The delay is considered a compliant risk management procedure, provided the insurer has submitted a preliminary dispute notice to the state's Guaranty Association.

Answer

The insurer is committing a regulatory violation by failing to make a good faith effort to promptly and fairly settle a claim where liability is undisputed.
The insurer's actions violate standard Unfair Claims Settlement Practices laws. Once an insurance company establishes that liability is reasonably clear, it has a statutory obligation to make a good faith attempt to settle the claim promptly and fairly. Intentionally withholding benefits to leverage a policyholder into accepting a substantially reduced payout directly breaches this regulation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the facts of the scenario regarding the insurer's conduct.
The insurer confirmed the insured's total disability and clear liability, yet intentionally withheld payments for six months to create financial hardship and force a lowball settlement.
Identifying the specific behavior is necessary to determine which unfair claims settlement practice applies.
2
Evaluate the behavior against standard Unfair Claims Settlement Practices laws.
The law explicitly prohibits failing to attempt in good faith to effectuate prompt, fair, and equitable settlements of claims in which liability has become reasonably clear.
Comparing the insurer's actions to statutory prohibitions determines if a regulatory violation occurred.
3
Select the option that correctly classifies the insurer's strategy.
The statement identifying the conduct as a regulatory violation for failing to make a good faith effort to settle an undisputed claim is the correct choice.
This option directly aligns with the NAIC Model Act provision violated in the scenario.

Key Concept

Failing to Effectuate Prompt and Fair Settlement
Rate this question

Topics

Unfair Claims Settlement Practices

More questions from this topic