Question

Difficulty: MediumUnfair Trade Practices

An independent insurance brokerage is brainstorming ways to increase commercial sales before the end of the year. The partners propose several different marketing and client acquisition strategies.

Which of the following proposed strategies would be classified as an unfair trade practice under state insurance regulations? (Select all that apply)

  1. Offering a prospective client a heavily discounted subscription to a payroll management software if they purchase a general liability policy.Answer
  2. Publishing a blog post that falsely claims a competing brokerage is on the verge of bankruptcy and is unable to pay its clients' claims.Answer
  3. C
    Providing existing commercial clients with a complimentary annual policy review to identify potential gaps in their current coverage limits.
  4. D
    Running a targeted advertisement that accurately compares the brokerage's customer satisfaction scores with publicly available industry averages.

Answer

The strategies classified as unfair trade practices are offering a discounted software subscription tied to a policy purchase (rebating) and publishing false claims about a competitor's financial status (defamation).
The correct selections describe clear violations of state insurance law: rebating (offering an outside incentive to secure a sale) and defamation (publishing false, damaging financial information about a competitor).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Evaluate the software subscription offer against legal definitions.
The offer provides an external item of value not stated in the insurance contract to induce a sale.
This matches the definition of rebating, making it an illegal unfair trade practice.
2
Evaluate the blog post claiming a competitor is bankrupt.
The post circulates false and derogatory information about another entity's financial condition.
This matches the definition of defamation, making it an illegal unfair trade practice.
3
Evaluate the complimentary policy review and the comparative advertisement.
Both activities represent truthful, standard business operations.
Factual advertising and standard insurance advisory services do not violate regulatory marketing standards.

Key Concept

Unfair Trade Practices (Rebating and Defamation)
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question