Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardFair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)

On May 1, an underwriter orders an investigative consumer report on a life insurance applicant. The insurer mails the required initial written disclosure regarding the report to the applicant on May 3. On May 5, the applicant submits a written request for a complete disclosure of the nature and scope of the investigation. The insurer mails this detailed information to the applicant on May 12. On May 20, based on information in the report, the insurer issues the policy but applies a substantial premium surcharge (a rate-up) due to hazardous activities. Because the policy was issued and not declined, the insurer does not send an adverse action notice. When the applicant contacts the insurance agent to dispute the accuracy of the report, the agent informs the applicant that the insurer will conduct an internal review to correct any errors made by the reporting agency.

Based on the provisions of the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), which of the following statements most accurately describes the insurer's compliance in this scenario?

  1. The insurer committed multiple violations: failing to provide the detailed investigation disclosure within 5 days of the request, failing to issue an adverse action notice for the premium surcharge, and improperly attempting to internally investigate the reporting agency's errors.Answer
  2. B
    The insurer's only violation was failing to issue an adverse action notice for the premium surcharge; the May 12 detailed disclosure was compliant because insurers have 10 days to respond, and insurers are legally required to internally investigate disputed report information.
  3. C
    The insurer violated the Act by failing to mail the initial disclosure on the exact date the report was ordered (May 1) and by failing to automatically include a free copy of the report with the issued policy, though the internal dispute review was handled correctly.
  4. D
    The insurer complied with all procedural timelines, but violated the Act because premium surcharges based on investigative reports require a 30-day waiting period before policy issuance to allow the applicant to dispute the findings with the reporting agency.

Answer

The insurer committed multiple violations: failing to provide the detailed investigation disclosure within 5 days of the request, failing to issue an adverse action notice for the premium surcharge, and improperly attempting to internally investigate the reporting agency's errors.
This option accurately identifies all three compliance failures in the scenario. First, the insurer took 7 days to provide the detailed disclosure, violating the strict 5-day rule. Second, a premium rate-up is legally classified as an adverse action under the FCRA, requiring a formal notice containing the reporting agency's contact information. Third, the insurer has no authority to investigate or correct a third-party reporting agency's files; the applicant must be directed to dispute inaccuracies directly with the Consumer Reporting Agency.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Evaluate the timeline for the initial disclosure of the investigative report.
The report was ordered on May 1 and the disclosure was mailed on May 3.
FCRA requires the initial disclosure to be mailed within 3 days of requesting an investigative consumer report. This action was compliant.
2
Evaluate the timeline for providing the detailed nature and scope of the investigation.
The applicant requested details on May 5, and the insurer mailed them on May 12 (7 days later). This is a statutory violation.
FCRA requires insurers to provide the detailed nature and scope of the investigation within 5 days of the applicant's written request.
3
Evaluate the handling of the premium surcharge (rate-up).
The insurer failed to send an adverse action notice, mistakenly assuming it was unnecessary since the policy was ultimately issued. This is a violation.
Under FCRA definitions, an adverse action includes any unfavorable change in terms or coverage amount, which explicitly includes applying a premium surcharge based on a consumer report.
4
Evaluate the dispute resolution process initiated by the agent.
The agent promised an internal review to correct the reporting agency's errors. This is a violation of proper protocol.
FCRA dictates that consumers must dispute inaccurate information directly with the Consumer Reporting Agency that generated the report. The insurer has neither the obligation nor the authority to alter the agency's data.

Key Concept

FCRA Investigative Reports and Adverse Action Procedures
Rate this question

Topics

Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)

More questions from this topic