Question

Difficulty: MediumInitial Premium and Premium Receipts

On September 8th, Thomas applies for a $100,000 whole life insurance policy, pays the initial premium, and is given a conditional insurability receipt. A medical exam is required, which he completes on September 15th. On September 22nd, Thomas dies unexpectedly before the policy is issued. During the subsequent underwriting review, the insurer determines that based on his medical exam results, Thomas would not have qualified for the standard premium rate and would have been classified as a substandard risk requiring a higher premium.

Based on these specific circumstances, how will the insurer respond to a claim for the death benefit?

  1. A
    The insurer will pay the full death benefit because the conditional receipt provided unconditional coverage starting on the date of the medical exam.
  2. B
    The insurer will pay a proportionally reduced death benefit based on what the initial premium would have purchased at the substandard rate.
  3. The insurer will deny the claim and refund the initial premium because Thomas was not insurable at the standard rate applied for.Answer
  4. D
    The insurer must pay the full death benefit because the agent created a legally binding contract by accepting the initial premium.

Answer

The insurer will deny the claim and refund the initial premium because Thomas was not insurable at the standard rate applied for.
A conditional insurability receipt provides coverage effective from the date of the application or medical exam (whichever is later) on the strict condition that the applicant is ultimately found insurable at the standard rate applied for. Because Thomas was determined to be a substandard risk, this condition was not met. As a result, no coverage was ever in force, and the insurer's only obligation is to return the initial premium to his estate.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the conditions of the receipt issued to the applicant.
The applicant received a conditional insurability receipt, which requires a medical exam.
The type of receipt dictates when and if coverage becomes effective before a policy is issued.
2
Determine the effective date rules for this specific receipt.
Coverage would theoretically be effective as of the date of the medical exam (September 15th), but only if the applicant is found insurable as a standard risk.
Conditional receipts trigger retroactive coverage only if the applicant meets the underwriting requirements for the rate originally applied for.
3
Evaluate the underwriting outcome against the receipt conditions.
The underwriter determined Thomas was a substandard risk, meaning he was not insurable at the standard premium rate.
Because the underwriting condition was not satisfied, the retroactive coverage never took effect, leaving the insurer liable only to return the premium.

Key Concept

Conditional Insurability Receipts and Effective Dates
Rate this question