Question

Difficulty: MediumFair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)

A commercial auto insurer decides to gather background information on a business owner by commissioning an investigative consumer report. After reviewing the findings, the underwriter decides to charge a significantly higher premium. Arrange the following procedural steps and consumer actions in the correct chronological sequence as mandated by the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA).

  1. 1The commercial auto insurer provides written notification to the business owner that an investigative consumer report may be requested.
  2. 2The business owner submits a written request to the insurer to understand the exact nature and scope of the background investigation.
  3. 3The insurer responds by providing a comprehensive written description outlining the scope of the investigative report.
  4. 4The underwriter issues the policy with a surcharged premium and simultaneously delivers an adverse action notice to the business owner.
  5. 5The business owner uses the contact information provided in the adverse action notice to request a free copy of their report from the credit agency.

Answer

The correct chronological sequence begins with the initial disclosure of the investigative report, followed by the consumer's request for scope details, the insurer's delivery of those details, the issuance of the adverse action notice due to the premium surcharge, and finally the consumer's request for a free copy of the report.
The sequence correctly follows the statutory FCRA timeline for investigative consumer reports. First, the applicant must be informed that a report may be ordered. Upon being notified, the applicant can request to know the scope of the investigation. The insurer is then legally required to provide those specific details within 5 days. Once the report is received and used to make an unfavorable underwriting decision—such as increasing the premium—the insurer must issue an adverse action notice. Finally, receiving this notice grants the applicant the right to request a free copy of the report directly from the reporting agency.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the initial disclosure requirement.
The insurer must first notify the consumer in writing that an investigative report may be requested.
The FCRA mandates that the subject must be informed within 3 days of the report being requested.
2
Determine the consumer's immediate right upon notification.
The business owner requests details about the nature and scope of the investigation.
Consumers have the right to request further details upon receiving the initial investigative report notification.
3
Identify the insurer's required response to the consumer's inquiry.
The insurer provides a written description outlining the scope of the investigation.
The FCRA requires the insurer to provide this detailed disclosure within 5 days of receiving the consumer's request.
4
Locate the adverse action event.
The insurer issues the policy with a surcharged premium and delivers an adverse action notice.
Charging a higher premium based on the report constitutes an adverse action, triggering the requirement to notify the consumer and provide the agency's contact information.
5
Identify the consumer's post-adverse action right.
The business owner requests a free copy of the report from the credit agency.
Following an adverse action notice, the consumer has 60 days to request a free copy of their report from the reporting agency.

Key Concept

Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) Investigative Report and Adverse Action Procedures
Rate this question