Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardInitial Premium and Premium Receipts

During a meeting on April 4th, Marcus applies for a $750,000 term life insurance policy. He provides a check covering the first six months' premium and receives a conditional insurability receipt from the producer. A mandatory paramedical exam is completed on April 9th. On April 14th, home office underwriters evaluate the exam results and determine Marcus does not qualify for the standard rate he applied for due to newly discovered health issues. They approve him as a substandard risk and issue the policy with a premium surcharge. On April 16th, before the producer can deliver the issued policy and collect the required additional premium, Marcus suffers a fatal heart attack. How will the insurance company legally respond to the death claim filed by the beneficiary?

  1. Deny the claim and refund the initial premium, because the substandard rating constituted a counteroffer that was never accepted.Answer
  2. B
    Pay the full $750,000 death benefit, because the mandatory medical exam was completed prior to his death, fulfilling the conditions of the receipt.
  3. C
    Deduct the required premium surcharge from the $750,000 face amount and pay the remaining balance to the beneficiary, as initial consideration was already provided.
  4. D
    Pay the full claim because the producer's issuance of the conditional receipt established apparent authority that immediate temporary coverage was in effect.

Answer

The insurer will deny the claim and refund the initial premium, because the substandard rating constituted a counteroffer that was never accepted.
When an applicant pays the initial premium and receives a conditional receipt, coverage is only effective retroactively if the insurer approves the application exactly as applied for (usually as a standard or preferred risk). Because the underwriters determined Marcus was a substandard risk and required a premium surcharge, the insurer legally rejected his original offer and issued a counteroffer. Since Marcus died before the policy could be delivered, the terms explained, and the additional premium collected (which would constitute acceptance of the counteroffer), no contract was ever formed. Therefore, the insurer's only obligation is to return the original premium.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the conditions of the premium receipt issued.
A conditional insurability receipt was issued, which generally makes coverage effective on the date of application or medical exam, whichever is later, PROVIDED the applicant is found insurable at the applied-for rate.
Understanding the specific type of receipt determines the timeline of coverage.
2
Evaluate the underwriting decision.
The underwriters approved the policy as a substandard risk with a premium surcharge, meaning he was not approved at the standard rate he applied for.
This is the critical pivot point; changing the risk classification alters the legal nature of the insurer's response.
3
Determine the legal effect of a substandard rating on a conditional receipt.
The approval at a substandard rate constitutes a rejection of the original offer and represents a counteroffer by the insurer.
Contract law requires a meeting of the minds; the insurer did not accept the exact terms of the applicant's offer.
4
Apply the facts to the time of death.
Since Marcus died before accepting the counteroffer and paying the required additional premium, no insurance contract ever came into existence.
This confirms that the insurer has no contractual obligation to pay the claim, only to return the unearned initial premium.

Key Concept

Conditional Receipts and Counteroffers
Rate this question

Topics

Initial Premium and Premium Receipts

More questions from this topic