On July 10, Elena applies for a $1,000,000 life insurance policy, pays the initial premium, and receives a conditional insurability receipt. The insurer requires a standard medical examination due to the policy's face amount, which she completes on July 15. On July 18, Elena dies in a fatal car accident. On July 20, unaware of her death, the insurer's underwriters review her medical results and determine she does not qualify for the standard rate she applied for. Instead, they approve a counteroffer for a substandard policy with a higher premium. How will the insurer handle the death benefit claim filed by Elena's beneficiary?
- The insurer will deny the death benefit claim and refund the initial premium to the beneficiary.Answer
- BThe insurer will pay the full $1,000,000 death benefit because coverage became retroactively effective on the date of the medical examination.
- CThe insurer will pay a reduced death benefit calculated by the amount of coverage the initial premium would have purchased at the substandard rate.
- DThe insurer will deny the claim and retain the initial premium because the counteroffer policy was legally issued by the underwriters on July 20.
Answer
The insurer will deny the death benefit claim and refund the initial premium to the beneficiary.
Under a conditional insurability receipt, coverage is only effective retroactively (to the later of the application date or medical exam date) if the applicant is ultimately found to be insurable at the applied-for risk classification and premium rate. Because the underwriters determined she was uninsurable at the applied rate and instead issued a counteroffer, the primary condition of the receipt was not met. Therefore, no life insurance coverage existed at the time of her death, and the insurer's only legal obligation is to refund the initial premium.
Step-by-Step Solution
Key Concept
Conditional Insurability Receipts and Substandard Counteroffers