Question

Difficulty: HardIdentification of Main Idea and Supporting Details

Read the passage below carefully:

For centuries, the ancient city of Kano in northern Nigeria has maintained a renowned leather tanning industry, utilizing traditional vegetable-tanning techniques derived from native plants such as the pods of the Acacia nilotica tree. Unlike modern industrial tanning methods that rely heavily on synthetic chromium salts—which generate toxic chemical effluents that contaminate surrounding soils and river systems—the indigenous Kano process is largely biodegradable and environmentally sustainable. However, despite these ecological advantages, the traditional leather sector faces mounting threats from rapid urbanization, shrinking supplies of raw hides, and unregulated cheap synthetic leather imports. Furthermore, while local tanners possess deep craft knowledge, the lack of modern wastewater treatment facilities in informal tanning clusters still leads to localized organic pollution. Consequently, environmental scientists argue that rather than replacing traditional tanning with industrial chemical processes, developmental policies should focus on modernizing waste management infrastructure while preserving the eco-friendly organic tanning formulations that have sustained the region's craft heritage for generations.

Match each excerpt or statement from the passage on the left to its correct functional role in the author's argument on the right.

  • Developmental policies should focus on upgrading waste infrastructure while safeguarding traditional organic tanning techniques.Central Thesis / Main Idea
  • The traditional Kano tanning method employs natural Acacia nilotica pods instead of toxic synthetic chromium compounds.Supporting Detail: Comparative Evidence of Ecological Sustainability
  • Urban encroachment, diminished raw hide availability, and synthetic imports undermine the traditional leather industry.Supporting Detail: Contextual Background on Economic Threats
  • The absence of centralized wastewater treatment in informal tanning areas results in localized environmental pollution.Supporting Detail: Qualifying Counter-Evidence / Operational Limitation

Answer

The statement advocating developmental policy reform to modernize waste treatment while protecting traditional organic tanning methods functions as the Central Thesis. The contrast between natural Acacia nilotica pods and toxic synthetic chromium compounds functions as Supporting Detail: Comparative Evidence of Ecological Sustainability. The mention of urban encroachment, hide shortages, and synthetic imports functions as Supporting Detail: Contextual Background on Economic Threats. Finally, the note on untreated wastewater resulting in localized pollution functions as Supporting Detail: Qualifying Counter-Evidence / Operational Limitation.
The correct pairings accurately classify the core policy recommendation as the main thesis, while correctly categorizing the comparative environmental facts, economic background, and operational caveats as supporting details.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the passage structure and identify discourse markers.
The text begins with factual descriptions of traditional tanning, moves to threats and caveats, and concludes with 'Consequently...', which introduces the main argument.
Discourse signals like 'Consequently' mark the logical culmination of an argument.
2
Distinguish the main claim from subordinate evidence.
The final sentence represents the author's primary recommendation, while earlier sentences provide evidence, context, and qualifying nuances.
The main idea is the central thesis supported by evidence, whereas supporting details elaborate on specific facts or qualifications.
3
Match each statement with its structural role in the argument.
Paired each passage statement correctly with its corresponding category.
Accurately categorizing passage statements validates understanding of thesis development.

Key Concept

Identification of Main Idea and Supporting Details
Rate this question