Question

Difficulty: MediumSummary: Identifying Central Arguments and Key Points

Read the passage below carefully.

In the mid-twentieth century, agrarian communities across southwestern Nigeria faced severe market volatility due to fluctuating global cocoa prices and exploited middleman networks. To counteract these economic vulnerabilities, local farmers began organizing informal collective unions aimed at pooling harvests and negotiating bulk prices directly with European buying houses.

As these grassroots associations expanded, regional agricultural boards recognized their potential and instituted formal cooperative frameworks. These frameworks provided rural farmers with access to subsidized fertilizers, standardized weighing scales, and low-interest credit schemes. Consequently, the quality of cocoa yield improved significantly, elevating the region's stature in the international market.

However, the rapid commercialization of cocoa also triggered unexpected socio-economic shifts. Smallholder farmers increasingly diverted land away from traditional food crops—such as yam and cassava—toward cocoa monoculture, creating localized food supply deficits.

In response to this growing food insecurity, modern agricultural policymakers have advocated for an integrated farming model. This contemporary strategy encourages cocoa farmers to intercrop shade-tolerant food crops and diversify into agro-processing, thereby balancing export revenue generation with regional food self-sufficiency.

Based on the text above, arrange the following central arguments in the logical order that reflects the progression of the author's overall argument from start to finish.

  1. 1Grassroots emergence of informal farmer unions to mitigate middleman exploitation and price volatility.
  2. 2Institutional support and formalization of cooperatives leading to improved cocoa quality and export strength.
  3. 3Emergence of food insecurity resulting from excessive land allocation to cocoa monoculture over food crops.
  4. 4Adoption of integrated farming strategies to reconcile export revenue generation with local sustenance needs.

Answer

The correct logical sequence places the grassroots emergence of informal farmer unions first, followed by institutional support and formalization of cooperatives, then the emergence of food insecurity due to cocoa monoculture, and finally the adoption of integrated farming strategies.
The passage follows a clear problem-institutionalization-side effect-resolution argument progression. First, cocoa farmers established informal unions to overcome price instability and middleman exploitation. Next, regional bodies formalized these into cooperatives, driving commercial success. Then, this success caused a negative shift towards monoculture and food deficits. Finally, agricultural experts proposed integrated farming as a balanced solution. Ordering the statements in this sequence reflects the precise development of the author's main points.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the primary thesis of the first paragraph
Recognize that the text begins with the initial economic struggles of cocoa farmers and their informal union formation to combat middleman exploitation.
Establishes the chronological and thematic baseline of the passage.
2
Analyze the structural shift in the second paragraph
Determine that state regional boards institutionalized these unions into formal cooperatives, boosting cocoa quality and market standing.
Shows how grassroots actions evolved into institutional success.
3
Trace the complication presented in the third paragraph
Identify that the success of cocoa commercialization caused a shift away from food crops (yam and cassava), creating localized food shortages.
Introduces the unintended consequence arising from the success described in the previous stage.
4
Synthesize the resolution in the final paragraph
Confirm that modern policymakers responded by recommending integrated farming models to balance cash crop production with food security.
Concludes the passage's argument by providing a modern synthesis to resolve the conflict.

Key Concept

Identifying passage progression and central argument sequence
Rate this question