Question

Difficulty: EasySummary: Identifying Central Arguments and Key Points

Read the passage below carefully and answer the question that follows.

For centuries, master builders across the Sudano-Sahelian region of West Africa relied on adobe—a sun-dried mixture of mud, straw, and organic additives—to construct dwellings and iconic community structures. These traditional earthen buildings were exceptionally well suited to the arid climate. The thick mud walls provided high thermal mass, absorbing heat during the blistering daytime and releasing it slowly during cooler desert nights, thereby maintaining comfortable indoor temperatures without artificial cooling. Furthermore, the materials were locally sourced, biodegradable, and economically accessible to all social strata.

However, the rapid influx of modern cement and concrete construction in recent decades has increasingly displaced traditional earth building techniques. Concrete structures, while perceived as symbols of modernity and durability, perform poorly in Sahelian thermal environments. Concrete walls rapidly absorb and transmit heat indoors, forcing a high reliance on energy-intensive air conditioning systems that remain out of reach for average households. Moreover, the production of industrial cement contributes significantly to carbon emissions, whereas traditional mud architecture represents a low-carbon, sustainable alternative. Although earthen structures demand periodic replastering after rainy seasons, their passive thermal regulation and environmental compatibility render them far superior for local climatic realities. Preserving and modernizing these indigenous building methods is therefore essential not only for architectural heritage but also for sustainable climate adaptation in the region.

Which of the following statements best summarizes the central argument of the passage?

  1. Traditional earthen architecture is thermally and environmentally superior to concrete construction in the Sahel, making its preservation essential for climate adaptation.Answer
  2. B
    Traditional mud buildings require routine replastering after the rainy season to maintain their structural integrity.
  3. C
    Modern concrete construction must be immediately prohibited across West Africa to eliminate industrial carbon emissions.
  4. D
    Concrete structures provide superior indoor cooling in arid climates because their walls rapidly absorb and transmit heat.

Answer

Traditional earthen architecture is thermally and environmentally superior to concrete construction in the Sahel, making its preservation essential for climate adaptation.
The passage evaluates the thermal efficiency, environmental benefits, and economic accessibility of traditional earthen architecture in the Sahel compared to modern concrete. The central argument synthesizes these points to stress that preserving indigenous building methods is vital for sustainable climate adaptation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the author's primary focus and overarching purpose throughout the passage.
The author contrasts traditional Sahelian earthen architecture with modern concrete structures, focusing on thermal mass, climate suitability, and sustainability.
The central argument must capture the main synthesis of the passage rather than isolated facts.
2
Evaluate potential summary statements against supporting details and unsupported claims.
Mentions of rainy season maintenance represent supporting details, while calls for total concrete bans are unsupported extrapolations.
Filtering out minor details and extreme claims isolates the main thesis.
3
Select the statement that encapsulates the main thesis of the text.
The statement asserting that traditional earthen architecture is superior for local climatic realities and essential for climate adaptation serves as the core summary.
It accurately reflects the passage's conclusive argument.

Key Concept

Identifying Central Arguments and Key Points
Rate this question