Question

Difficulty: MediumThematic Analysis and Central Messages

Read the excerpt below from a prescribed drama and answer the question that follows:

ELDER KALE: You bring us light contained in wires, yet you switch off the sun that guided our forefathers. What is a lit city to a people whose roots lie drowned under twenty fathoms of dammed water?
ENGINEER NDUKA: Progress demands sacrifice, Papa. A thousand villages will draw power from this valley.
ELDER KALE: Sacrifice is given willingly; what you demand is amnesia.

In the excerpt above, Elder Kale's assertion that the project demands 'amnesia' primarily underscores which central theme?

  1. The conflict between technological modernization and the preservation of historical identity and cultural memoryAnswer
  2. B
    The literal preference for natural sunlight over artificial electric lighting in rural communities
  3. C
    The economic benefits of delivering hydroelectric power to surrounding villages
  4. D
    The political struggle for leadership between younger educated professionals and traditional village elders

Answer

The conflict between technological modernization and the preservation of historical identity and cultural memory
The correct option accurately captures the central message of the dialogue. Elder Kale argues that building the dam submerged ancestral roots and forced the community to forget their heritage ('amnesia'), highlighting the tragic cost of technological advancement when it destroys historical identity.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the dramatic dialogue for core motifs
Identified contrasting motifs: 'light contained in wires' / 'power' (technological progress) versus 'drowned roots' / 'amnesia' (loss of heritage and history).
Thematic analysis requires examining how symbolic language expresses underlying ideological positions.
2
Evaluate Elder Kale's key declaration
The phrase 'what you demand is amnesia' directly equates the displacement caused by the hydroelectric dam with forced forgetting of ancestral identity.
The final line synthesizes the character's argument against sacrificing historical continuity for material development.

Key Concept

Thematic Analysis and Central Messages
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question