Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardVerbs, Tenses, and Aspect

During the cross-examination, the defense attorney argued as though his client ________ present at the scene of the incident, despite overwhelming evidence placing him elsewhere at the time.

Which of the following verb forms grammatically completes the sentence above?

  1. had not beenAnswer
  2. B
    was not
  3. C
    has not been
  4. D
    would not be

Answer

The correct option is 'had not been'.
The phrase 'as though' (like 'as if') requires a subjunctive or unreal tense shift when describing hypothetical or counterfactual situations. Because the main clause is set in the past ('argued') and refers to an event that did not actually occur in the past, the past perfect tense ('had not been') is mandatory to indicate unreal past aspect.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the main clause and temporal framework
The reporting verb 'argued' establishes a past-tense narrative context describing a completed event in the past.
Determining the time frame of the main clause governs the sequence of tenses in subordinate clauses.
2
Examine the grammatical function of the conjunction 'as though'
'As though' introduces a hypothetical or counterfactual (unreal) condition.
When 'as though' or 'as if' describes a past situation that is contrary to fact, the past perfect mood/aspect must be employed.
3
Select the verb form that satisfies unreal past requirements
'had not been' provides the requisite past perfect aspect to indicate counterfactual past reality.
Unreal past events governed by conjunctions of comparison like 'as if' or 'as though' require the past perfect form to shift back from the past reference point.

Key Concept

Unreal Past and Subjunctive Mood with 'As though' / 'As if'
Rate this question

Topics

Verbs, Tenses, and Aspect

More questions from this topic