Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardWriter's Purpose, Tone, Mood, and Attitude

Read the passage below carefully:

"The hasty abandonment of traditional earthen architecture across West African municipalities in favor of imported concrete and glass monoliths represents a triumph of aesthetic mimicry over environmental logic. While modernists champion glass facades as symbols of cosmopolitan sophistication, these structures create internal microclimates akin to greenhouse ovens, demanding immense energy loads for artificial refrigeration. Meanwhile, centuries-old earthen construction techniques—masterfully engineered for thermal inertia and passive cooling—are dismissed by municipal planners as rustic relics. By prioritizing superficial prestige over functional sustainability, contemporary urban development does not merely discard ancestral building science; it actively fuels an energy crisis under the guise of progress."

Which option best captures the writer's attitude toward contemporary urban architectural trends in West Africa?

  1. Condemnatory and sarcastic toward the uncritical adoption of energy-inefficient modern buildings.Answer
  2. B
    Gloomy and melancholic regarding the discomfort experienced by urban inhabitants inside modern structures.
  3. C
    Nostalgic and superstitious regarding the spiritual value of traditional building customs.
  4. D
    Objective and neutral in contrasting traditional earthen methods with modern concrete design.

Answer

The writer's attitude is condemnatory and sarcastic toward the uncritical adoption of energy-inefficient modern buildings.
The correct option accurately reflects the writer's scathing critique of modern urban architecture. Through phrases like 'aesthetic mimicry' and 'under the guise of progress', the writer expresses clear condemnation mixed with irony regarding the replacement of sustainable traditional building science with energy-consuming glass structures.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the passage for emotive and evaluative word choices (diction).
Identified terms such as 'aesthetic mimicry', 'greenhouse ovens', 'superficial prestige', and 'guise of progress'.
Diction reveals the author's underlying perspective and tone towards the topic.
2
Evaluate the author's central stance on modern versus traditional architecture.
The author clearly opposes glass monoliths as environmentally flawed and praises traditional earthen construction as masterfully engineered.
Understanding the contrast helps determine whether the tone is supportive, neutral, or critical.
3
Synthesize the diction and stance to determine the specific tone/attitude.
The combination of severe disapproval and mocking phrases ('triumph of aesthetic mimicry', 'under the guise of progress') establishes a condemnatory and sarcastic attitude.
Matching tone indicators directly to standard tone descriptors ensures an accurate interpretation.

Key Concept

Identifying Writer's Tone and Attitude through Diction and Rhetorical Stance
Rate this question

Topics

Writer's Purpose, Tone, Mood, and Attitude

More questions from this topic