Question

Difficulty: MediumBudget Line and Budget Constraint

An equal proportionate increase in a consumer's nominal income and the prices of both goods consumed will cause the budget line to shift outward parallel to its original position.

Answer: Answer

Answer

The statement is False. An equal proportionate increase in nominal income and all commodity prices leaves real purchasing power and the budget line completely unchanged.
The statement is false because multiplying nominal income and all product prices by the same scalar leaves real purchasing power and relative price ratios unchanged, keeping the budget line in its exact original position.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
State the standard budget line equation and intercepts
The budget equation is PXX+PYY=IP_X X + P_Y Y = I, with horizontal intercept X=IPXX = \frac{I}{P_X}, vertical intercept Y=IPYY = \frac{I}{P_Y}, and slope PXPY-\frac{P_X}{P_Y}.
Establishing the mathematical parameters of the budget constraint is necessary to evaluate positional changes.
2
Apply a proportional scaling factor k>1k > 1 to nominal income and prices
The new equation becomes (kPX)X+(kPY)Y=kI(k P_X) X + (k P_Y) Y = k I.
An equal percentage increase scales nominal income and both prices by the same factor kk.
3
Simplify the scaled budget equation and determine the effect on the line
Dividing both sides by kk yields PXX+PYY=IP_X X + P_Y Y = I. The new intercepts kIkPX=IPX\frac{k I}{k P_X} = \frac{I}{P_X} and kIkPY=IPY\frac{k I}{k P_Y} = \frac{I}{P_Y} are identical to the original intercepts.
Because neither the intercepts nor the slope change, the budget line does not shift outward.

Key Concept

Homogeneity of the Budget Constraint (Real vs. Nominal Changes)
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question