Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumCommercial Policy and Trade Barriers (Tariffs, Quotas, Embargoes, and Subsidies)

To protect its domestic textile industry, a country decides to restrict foreign imports by setting a physical limit on the quantity of fabrics allowed into the country annually, rather than imposing an import duty. Which of the following statements correctly highlights a key distinction in the economic consequence of applying an import quota instead of an import tariff?

  1. An import quota generates price premiums (quota rents) that accrue to import license holders or foreign suppliers unless auctioned, whereas a tariff raises tax revenue directly for the government.Answer
  2. B
    An import quota acts as an administrative price ceiling that artificially suppresses the domestic market price below the world price level.
  3. C
    An import quota promotes export diversification by directly earning foreign currency reserves for the host government.
  4. D
    An import quota affects only the capital account of the balance of payments without altering the merchandise trade balance.

Answer

An import quota generates price premiums (quota rents) that accrue to import license holders or foreign suppliers unless auctioned, whereas a tariff raises tax revenue directly for the government.
While both tariffs and quotas reduce foreign supply and increase domestic consumer prices, a tariff directly increases public revenue through customs duties. Under a non-auctioned quota, the revenue gap created by higher domestic prices (quota rent) goes to foreign exporters or domestic license holders.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the functional mechanism of an import tariff versus an import quota.
A tariff is a tax per unit of imported goods, increasing price and providing customs duty revenue to the government treasury. A quota places a hard limit on foreign quantity.
Both instruments reduce foreign supply and raise domestic prices, but their distribution of economic surplus differs.
2
Evaluate the destination of the excess monetary gap between world price and domestic price under a quota.
The domestic price rises to clear the market at the restricted quota supply level. The resulting gap between the world price and the domestic price forms a scarcity surplus known as quota rent.
Because no tax is collected by customs, this quota rent benefits importers allocated the licenses (or foreign exporters) rather than the public treasury.

Key Concept

Economic Differences Between Tariffs and Import Quotas (Quota Rents vs Government Revenue)
Rate this question

Topics

Commercial Policy and Trade Barriers (Tariffs, Quotas, Embargoes, and Subsidies)

More questions from this topic