Question

Difficulty: MediumIdentification of Main Idea and Supporting Details

Read the passage below carefully:

Across the Sahelian belt of West Africa, traditional earthen architecture is undergoing a critical re-evaluation by modern urban planners. For decades, Western-style concrete structures dominated municipal development, despite their tendency to trap radiant heat and drastically increase indoor temperatures. Earthen buildings—constructed using locally sourced clay, straw, and laterite—naturally regulate thermal mass, absorbing daytime heat and releasing it slowly during cooler desert nights. Additionally, thick clay walls and shaded internal courtyards significantly reduce the energy load required for mechanical ventilation. While critics once dismissed earth-based construction as primitive or short-lived, recent architectural trials in cities like Niamey and Ouagadougou demonstrate that refined soil-stabilization techniques render these structures both durable and rain-resistant. Beyond thermal efficiency, promoting earthen construction supports localized economies by decreasing reliance on expensive imported cement. Consequently, integrating indigenous building wisdom with contemporary engineering offers a viable, sustainable framework for combating extreme urban heat across the region.

Which of the following best expresses the main idea of the passage?

  1. A
    Refined soil-stabilization techniques in cities like Niamey make clay buildings resistant to rainfall.
  2. Integrating traditional earthen architectural methods with modern engineering offers a sustainable solution to regional urban heat.Answer
  3. C
    A complete ban on imported cement is necessary to revitalize municipal construction in West Africa.
  4. D
    Western-style concrete structures remain superior to traditional buildings in reducing indoor mechanical ventilation loads.

Answer

Integrating traditional earthen architectural methods with modern engineering offers a sustainable solution to regional urban heat.
The passage evaluates the problem of urban heat trapped by concrete buildings and presents traditional earthen architecture enhanced by modern engineering as the primary solution. The statement identifying the integration of traditional earthen architecture with modern engineering as a sustainable framework directly encapsulates the central thesis.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the passage structure and identify the core thesis.
The passage discusses the thermal and economic drawbacks of concrete buildings, highlights the benefits of earthen architecture, and concludes that combining indigenous knowledge with contemporary engineering provides a sustainable framework against urban heat.
The central idea must encompass the entire scope of the text rather than focusing on a single paragraph or example.
2
Differentiate between main arguments and supporting evidence.
Specific facts—such as soil stabilization trials in Niamey or reduced cement imports—act as supporting evidence illustrating why earthen structures are practical and beneficial.
Supporting details provide evidence for the main thesis but do not constitute the main thesis itself.
3
Evaluate the options against the identified central thesis.
The option stating that integrating traditional earthen architectural methods with modern engineering offers a sustainable solution directly reflects the concluding thesis of the passage.
It accurately captures the primary purpose and scope of the text without overextending or narrowing the focus.

Key Concept

Distinguishing Main Idea from Supporting Details
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question