Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumElectoral Management Bodies and Conduct of Elections

Following a gubernatorial election in Nigeria, a aggrieved political party candidate files a petition to challenge the validity of the declared election results, while the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) simultaneously seeks to try a presiding officer charged with ballot box snatching and forgery of result sheets. Which judicial bodies possess the statutory jurisdiction to determine the election petition and try the criminal offence, respectively?

  1. An Election Petition Tribunal for the election petition, and a standard Criminal Court (High Court or Magistrate Court) for the criminal prosecution.Answer
  2. B
    An Election Petition Tribunal for both the civil election petition and the criminal prosecution of the presiding officer.
  3. C
    A regular State High Court for both the civil election petition and the prosecution of the electoral offence.
  4. D
    The Federal High Court for the election petition, and an Election Petition Tribunal for the criminal prosecution.

Answer

An Election Petition Tribunal hears the election petition, while a standard Criminal Court (High Court or Magistrate Court) handles the criminal prosecution.
Under Nigerian constitutional and electoral law, post-election challenges regarding who won an election are heard exclusively by Election Petition Tribunals. Conversely, criminal offences committed during elections—such as ballot box snatching or falsification of results—must be prosecuted in standard criminal courts (High Courts or Magistrate Courts).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the nature of the dispute involving the candidate's challenge to the declared results.
Determined that challenging an election outcome is an electoral dispute falling under the exclusive original jurisdiction of an Election Petition Tribunal.
Section 285 of the 1999 Constitution of Nigeria (as amended) establishes Election Petition Tribunals to hear disputes regarding the validity of elections.
2
Identify the nature of the proceedings against the presiding officer for ballot box snatching and forgery.
Determined that ballot box snatching and forgery are electoral offences of a criminal nature governed by the Electoral Act.
Criminal offences arising from elections must be prosecuted by INEC in regular courts exercising criminal jurisdiction (Magistrate Courts or High Courts).
3
Select the option that correctly pairs the two distinct judicial forums.
The correct combination specifies an Election Petition Tribunal for the petition and a standard criminal court for prosecution.
Election Petition Tribunals cannot try criminal cases or sentence offenders, and regular courts do not determine post-election return petitions.

Key Concept

Jurisdictional separation between Election Petition Tribunals (civil/electoral disputes) and regular Criminal Courts (prosecution of electoral offences).
Rate this question

Topics

Electoral Management Bodies and Conduct of Elections