Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardSovereignty: Concept, Types, Characteristics, and Limitations

A sovereign state's voluntary ratification of binding international treaties and adherence to international law legally extinguishes its internal legal sovereignty.

Answer: Answer

Answer

False. Voluntary ratification of international treaties is a manifestation of external sovereignty and does not extinguish internal legal sovereignty.
The statement is false because entering into international treaties is an assertion of external sovereignty. An independent state voluntarily undertakes international duties while retaining its fundamental constitutional supremacy and the legal capacity to withdraw from treaties.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Distinguish between internal legal sovereignty and external sovereignty.
Internal legal sovereignty refers to the supreme constitutional power to make and enforce laws within a territory, whereas external sovereignty relates to international independence and recognition.
Differentiating these concepts clarifies how international legal obligations interact with state power.
2
Assess the legal effect of international obligations on state authority.
While international treaties create external limitations on a state's freedom of action, entry into them is a voluntary exercise of sovereign authority, and the state's internal legal supremacy remains constitutionally intact.
External constraints on state policy do not negate the legal sovereign authority from which compliance derives.

Key Concept

Sovereignty: External Limitations vs. Legal Sovereignty
Rate this question

Topics

Sovereignty: Concept, Types, Characteristics, and Limitations

More questions from this topic