Question

Difficulty: HardComparison of Market Structures: Economic Efficiency and Consumer Welfare

In long-run equilibrium, a monopolistically competitive firm achieves productive efficiency because free entry and exit eliminate economic profits, driving price down to equal average total cost.

Answer: Answer

Answer

The statement is False. Long-run equilibrium in monopolistic competition yields zero economic profit (P=ATCP = ATC), but because the firm's demand curve slopes downward, production occurs to the left of the minimum ATC point, creating excess capacity and failing to achieve productive efficiency.
The statement is false because product differentiation gives monopolistically competitive firms market power, resulting in a downward-sloping demand curve. Although free entry forces long-run economic profits to zero (P=ATCP = ATC), tangency occurs on the falling segment of the average total cost curve, leading to excess capacity rather than productive efficiency.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Define productive efficiency in market structure analysis
Productive efficiency requires that goods be produced at the lowest possible per-unit cost, which occurs where price or marginal cost equals the minimum of average total cost (P=minimum ATCP = \text{minimum } ATC).
This ensures societal resources are not wasted in the production process.
2
Analyze the long-run equilibrium of a monopolistically competitive firm
Free entry and exit drive economic profits to zero, meaning P=ATCP = ATC. However, because products are differentiated, each firm faces a downward-sloping demand curve (P>MCP > MC).
A downward-sloping demand curve can only be tangent to a U-shaped ATC curve at a point where the ATC curve is still sloping downward.
3
Compare actual output to the productively efficient output level
Output is produced at a level where ATC>minimum ATCATC > \text{minimum } ATC. The difference between the output that minimizes ATC and the actual output produced is known as excess capacity.
Because the firm operates with excess capacity and does not produce at minimum ATC, productive efficiency is not achieved.

Key Concept

Excess Capacity and Productive Efficiency in Monopolistic Competition
Rate this question