Question

Difficulty: HardIdentification of Main Idea and Supporting Details

Read the passage below carefully:

While mangrove restoration projects along the Gulf of Guinea are frequently praised by international environmental agencies primarily for their capacity to sequester blue carbon, their most critical socio-economic contribution lies in protecting indigenous artisanal fisheries from escalating coastal erosion and storm surges. Recent field studies across the Niger Delta reveal that intact mangrove ecosystems function as irreplaceable nursery habitats for nearly eighty percent of commercially harvested local fish species. Furthermore, coastal communities that actively maintained natural mangrove buffers suffered significantly less infrastructure damage during recent seasonal flooding compared to areas dominated by artificial sea walls. Although carbon credit monetization schemes offer potential long-term financial windfalls, local economic resilience depends far more immediately on the tangible biomass protection and shoreline stabilization that living mangroves continuously provide. Consequently, environmental policymakers who prioritize international carbon trading markets over local ecological maintenance risk undermining the immediate food security and livelihood stability of coastal populations.

Which of the following statements best expresses the main idea of the passage?

  1. Living mangroves primarily sustain coastal livelihoods and food security through shoreline protection and fishery support rather than serving merely as carbon sequestration sites.Answer
  2. B
    Intact mangrove ecosystems across the Niger Delta function as nursery habitats for nearly eighty percent of local commercial fish species.
  3. C
    Carbon credit monetization schemes are fundamentally ineffective and should be entirely abolished by international environmental agencies.
  4. D
    Artificial sea walls provide far superior infrastructure protection against extreme seasonal flooding than natural mangrove buffers.

Answer

The main idea of the passage is that living mangroves primarily sustain coastal livelihoods and food security through shoreline protection and fishery support rather than serving merely as carbon sequestration sites.
The passage repeatedly stresses that while international bodies focus on blue carbon, the most critical contribution of mangroves is their immediate benefit to local fisheries and coastal defense. The correct option accurately encapsulates this central thesis.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the text structure to separate the primary claim from supportive evidence.
The author contrasts global praise for mangrove carbon sequestration with their true primary value: protecting local fisheries and shorelines.
Identifying the central claim requires distinguishing overarching thesis statements from supporting field data and examples.
2
Evaluate how supporting details reinforce the central claim.
The statistics on fish species (80%) and flood resilience illustrate why local ecological maintenance is essential for food security and livelihood stability.
Supporting evidence must not be mistaken for the comprehensive thesis of the passage.
3
Select the option that synthesizes the entire message without misinterpreting facts or over-generalizing.
The statement highlighting local livelihood and shoreline protection over mere carbon sequestration accurately synthesizes the passage.
The correct answer must encompass the author's primary argument while remaining faithful to the passage context.

Key Concept

Identifying Main Idea versus Supporting Details
Rate this question