Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumAdjectives, Adverbs, and Modifiers

Which of the following sentences correctly places the modifier to express the intended meaning without grammatical error?

  1. Having carefully examined the ancient manuscripts, the archivist cataloged the rare historical documents.Answer
  2. B
    Having carefully examined the ancient manuscripts, the rare historical documents were cataloged by the archivist.
  3. C
    Having carefully examined the ancient manuscripts, the archivist cataloged the documents highly fast.
  4. D
    Having carefully examined the ancient manuscripts, the archivist cataloged the documents with stationary care.

Answer

The sentence where the introductory participial phrase directly modifies the archivist who performed the examination is grammatically correct.
The correct option properly matches the introductory participial phrase with the noun that actually performed the action ('the archivist'), ensuring clear grammatical modification and avoiding structural ambiguity.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the introductory modifier phrase
Identified 'Having carefully examined the ancient manuscripts' as a participial modifier requiring a logical animate subject immediately following the comma.
Participial phrases must clearly and logically attach to the agent performing the action.
2
Evaluate the subject following the comma in each candidate sentence
In the correct sentence, 'the archivist' immediately follows the introductory clause, providing the logical subject who examined the manuscripts.
Placing 'the rare historical documents' after the clause creates a dangling modifier, as documents cannot examine themselves.
3
Verify modifier precision and collocation accuracy in the main clause
The adverb 'carefully' and adjective 'rare historical' are appropriately used without unnatural collocations or homophone errors.
Ensures full compliance with Standard English grammatical structure for modifiers.

Key Concept

Participial Modifier Placement and Diction Integrity
Rate this question

Topics

Adjectives, Adverbs, and Modifiers

More questions from this topic