Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardThe Richards Constitution of 1946 and Regionalism

Nationalist leaders strongly criticized the Richards Constitution of 1946 for instituting what they termed 'regionalism without federalism.' Which of the following constitutional arrangements under the 1946 framework best justifies this nationalist critique?

  1. The Regional Houses of Assembly served primarily as advisory and deliberative bodies without independent legislative or financial autonomy, leaving ultimate legislative authority vested in the Central Legislative Council.Answer
  2. B
    The constitution formally divided legislative responsibilities into Exclusive and Concurrent lists, establishing autonomous regional executive councils headed by regional premiers.
  3. C
    The central colonial government abolished the central executive organ and devolved full sovereign legislative power directly to the regional houses of assembly.
  4. D
    The regional legislative assemblies were composed entirely of members elected through direct universal adult suffrage across all provinces in Nigeria.

Answer

The Regional Houses of Assembly served primarily as advisory and deliberative bodies without independent legislative or financial autonomy, leaving ultimate legislative authority vested in the Central Legislative Council.
The nationalist critique of 'regionalism without federalism' stems from the fact that while the Richards Constitution established three administrative regions, the Regional Houses of Assembly were granted no independent law-making authority or financial powers. They functioned merely as advisory bodies to the Central Legislative Council in Lagos, preserving a unitary system of colonial administration.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the core structural innovation of the Richards Constitution (1946).
Identified that the 1946 Constitution introduced formal regional divisions (Northern, Western, and Eastern Regions) and created Regional Houses of Assembly.
Understanding the administrative setup introduced by Sir Arthur Richards is necessary to evaluate nationalist criticisms.
2
Evaluate the legislative and financial powers granted to the regional assemblies under the 1946 framework.
Determined that regional assemblies could only deliberate on regional matters and submit recommendations or draft estimates to the Central Legislative Council in Lagos.
Nationalist leaders criticized the constitution because the regions lacked genuine law-making and revenue-raising powers.
3
Distinguish the 1946 Richards Constitution from the 1954 Lyttelton Constitution.
Confirmed that full legislative division of powers, regional autonomy, and true federalism were established in 1954 under the Lyttelton Constitution, not in 1946.
This distinction exposes common student misconceptions regarding the constitutional origins of Nigerian federalism.

Key Concept

The Richards Constitution of 1946 and Regionalism
Rate this question

Topics

The Richards Constitution of 1946 and Regionalism

More questions from this topic