Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardParliamentary System of Government

In a classic parliamentary system of government, the executive cabinet suffers a defeat in the legislature during a vote on the national annual budget bill. If the Prime Minister attempts to remain in office without calling for new elections, what is the constitutional implication of this defeat?

  1. A
    The ceremonial Head of State automatically assumes supreme executive power and directs government operations until new elections.
  2. The loss of a financial supply bill serves as an implicit vote of no confidence, legally requiring the cabinet to resign or request parliamentary dissolution.Answer
  3. C
    The judicial arm of government intervenes by issuing an injunction to compel the legislature to approve the budget.
  4. D
    The administrative leadership of the civil service assumes political executive control over government ministries to administer funds.

Answer

The defeat on a financial supply bill constitutes an implicit loss of confidence, constitutionally requiring the executive cabinet to resign or seek parliamentary dissolution.
In a parliamentary system of government, the executive relies continuously on the confidence of the legislature to govern. A defeat on a vital money or supply bill (such as the national budget) is conventionally regarded as a loss of confidence. As a result, the Prime Minister and the cabinet are constitutionally required to resign or advise the Head of State to dissolve parliament for a fresh general election.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the constitutional nature of supply and budget bills in a parliamentary system.
Money bills (budget/supply) are central to governance because an executive cannot function without legislative financial authorization.
Passing a budget demonstrates that the Prime Minister and cabinet maintain the support of the parliamentary majority.
2
Determine the legal and conventional consequences of losing a vote on a supply bill.
Defeat on a supply bill is conventionally treated as equivalent to a formal vote of no confidence.
Without parliamentary financial backing, the government loses its authority to govern.
3
Identify the mandatory constitutional recourse available to the executive.
The Prime Minister must either submit the resignation of the entire cabinet or request the ceremonial Head of State to dissolve parliament for fresh general elections.
Cabinet accountability to the legislature requires immediate resignation or public re-election when confidence is lost.

Key Concept

Supply Bill Defeat as a Vote of No Confidence in Parliamentary Systems
Rate this question

Topics

Parliamentary System of Government

More questions from this topic