Question

Difficulty: HardSovereignty: Concept, Types, Characteristics, and Limitations

Classical political theorist Jean Bodin defined sovereignty as absolute, perpetual, and indivisible supreme power. However, in a constitutional federal republic, governmental powers are legally shared between the central government and federating units. Which statement accurately explains how sovereign authority is structured and limited within such a federal system?

  1. Internal sovereignty is bounded by constitutional supremacy, which divides legislative competencies and prevents any single tier of government from exercising absolute power.Answer
  2. B
    Legal sovereignty shifts entirely to the electorate, converting the formal federal structure into a pure political body governed by de facto administrative power.
  3. C
    Coercive physical power replaces constitutional authority, forcing federating units to obey central government directives through non-legitimate force.
  4. D
    External sovereignty is fragmented, allowing federating states to independently negotiate international treaties and exercise supreme legal authority over foreign relations.

Answer

Internal sovereignty is bounded by constitutional supremacy, which divides legislative competencies and prevents any single tier of government from exercising absolute power.
In a federal republic, the constitution is the supreme law of the land. It divides governance powers between the central authority and federating units, thereby serving as an internal legal limitation on state sovereignty. This contrasts with Jean Bodin's classical monarchical view of absolute and undivided sovereignty, as constitutional supremacy ensures no single organ or tier of government holds unlimited authority.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze Jean Bodin's traditional concept of sovereignty.
Bodin defined sovereignty as undivided, absolute, and unlimited power within a state.
Establishing the classical theoretical baseline allows comparison with modern constitutional practice.
2
Examine how a federal system structures power under a written constitution.
A federal constitution legally divides governmental functions into exclusive, concurrent, and residual lists between central and regional authorities.
This division acts as an internal limitation on government power, as neither tier possesses unlimited power.
3
Identify the primary mechanism limiting sovereignty in a federation.
Constitutional supremacy legally restricts both central and state bodies, modifying Bodin's concept of absolute indivisible power.
Constitutional provisions enforce legal boundaries and judicial review over all levels of government.

Key Concept

Internal Limitations on Sovereignty in Federal Systems
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question