Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumComparative Analysis of Centralized and Segmentary Pre-Colonial Systems

In pre-colonial Nigerian political structures, segmentary societies were defined by a centralized executive monarch and formal tax collection, whereas centralized emirates operated through decentralized village assemblies and age-grade consensus.

Answer: Answer

Answer

The statement is False. Centralized pre-colonial Nigerian polities were defined by monarchical executive hierarchies and formal tax structures, whereas segmentary societies relied on decentralized village assemblies and age-grade consensus.
The statement incorrectly swaps the structural characteristics of pre-colonial political systems in Nigeria. Centralized systems (such as the Hausa-Fulani Emirate system and the Oyo Empire) were characterized by a defined executive monarch, administrative titleholders, judicial hierarchies, and regular taxation. In contrast, segmentary societies (such as the pre-colonial Igbo system) were acephalous, relying on village assembly democracy (Ama-ala), age grades, cults, and title holders to achieve political consensus without a central sovereign.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Examine the political characteristics attributed to segmentary societies in the stem statement.
The statement claims segmentary societies operated under a centralized executive monarch and formal tax collection.
To verify if segmentary political systems possessed central monarchical and tax institutions.
2
Compare these claims against the historical organization of pre-colonial Nigerian systems.
Centralized systems (e.g., Hausa-Fulani Emirates) maintained hierarchical executive authority with organized tax structures (Zakat, Jangali), while segmentary societies (e.g., Igbo) lacked a single central sovereign, utilizing lineage assemblies and age grades for decision-making.
To identify that the stem statement reverses the defining features of centralized and segmentary systems.

Key Concept

Comparative Structural Features of Centralized and Segmentary Pre-Colonial Systems
Rate this question

Topics

Comparative Analysis of Centralized and Segmentary Pre-Colonial Systems