Question

Difficulty: MediumFactors Affecting Preferential Discharge of Ions

During the electrolysis of concentrated hydrochloric acid (HCl(aq)HCl_{(aq)}) using inert graphite electrodes, a gaseous product XX is evolved at the anode while gas YY is evolved at the cathode. Which option correctly identifies gas XX, gas YY, and the primary factor responsible for the preferential discharge that yields gas XX?

  1. Gas XX is Cl2Cl_2, Gas YY is H2H_2, driven by the high concentration of chloride ions.Answer
  2. B
    Gas XX is O2O_2, Gas YY is H2H_2, driven by the position of hydroxide ions in the electrochemical series.
  3. C
    Gas XX is H2H_2, Gas YY is Cl2Cl_2, driven by the high concentration of hydrogen ions.
  4. D
    Gas XX is O2O_2, Gas YY is Cl2Cl_2, driven by the chemical nature of the graphite electrodes.

Answer

Gas XX is Cl2Cl_2, Gas YY is H2H_2, driven by the high concentration of chloride ions.
In concentrated hydrochloric acid, the ions migrating to the anode are Cl−Cl^- and OH−OH^-. Because the solution is concentrated, the concentration of Cl−Cl^- ions is far higher than that of OH−OH^-. Consequently, the concentration factor predominates over position in the electrochemical series, resulting in Cl−Cl^- being preferentially oxidized to chlorine gas (Cl2Cl_2). At the cathode, H+H^+ ions gain electrons to form hydrogen gas (H2H_2).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the ions present in concentrated hydrochloric acid (HCl(aq)HCl_{(aq)}).
The cations present are H+H^+ (from HClHCl and H2OH_2O) and the anions present are Cl−Cl^- and OH−OH^-.
Hydrochloric acid ionizes completely in water into H+H^+ and Cl−Cl^-, alongside minor autoionization of water.
2
Determine the reaction taking place at the anode (positive electrode).
Chloride ions (Cl−Cl^-) are discharged preferentially to form chlorine gas (Cl2Cl_2).
Although OH−OH^- is higher in the electrochemical series than Cl−Cl^-, the significantly higher concentration of Cl−Cl^- in concentrated HClHCl overrides position in the series.
3
Determine the reaction taking place at the cathode (negative electrode).
Hydrogen ions (H+H^+) are discharged to form hydrogen gas (H2H_2).
H+H^+ is the only cation present in solution, gaining electrons at the cathode.

Key Concept

Concentration effect on preferential discharge of anions during electrolysis
Rate this question