Question

Difficulty: Very hardContinuous and Discontinuous Variation

A geneticist analyzed the phenotypic distribution of two traits in a population of fruit flies (*Drosophila melanogaster*): wing length measured in millimeters and eye color (red versus white). When cultures were reared across a range of ambient temperatures, the wing lengths across the population formed a smooth spectrum whose mean value shifted significantly with temperature changes. In contrast, eye color consistently segregated into two discrete, non-overlapping categories in predictable Mendelian ratios regardless of rearing temperature. What does this observation indicate regarding the genetic control and environmental sensitivity of these two traits?

  1. Wing length is polygenic and influenced by environmental factors, whereas eye color is monogenic and unaffected by temperature variations.Answer
  2. B
    Wing length displays discontinuous variation regulated by a single gene, whereas eye color demonstrates continuous variation governed by multiple additive genes.
  3. C
    Both traits are polygenic, but wing length shows codominance while eye color undergoes thermal inactivation at higher temperatures.
  4. D
    Wing length is governed strictly by temperature without genetic contribution, while eye color is caused by a chromosomal aberration.

Answer

Wing length is polygenic and influenced by environmental factors, whereas eye color is monogenic and unaffected by temperature variations.
Continuous variation (such as wing length) is quantitative, controlled by multiple additive genes (polygenic inheritance), and readily modified by environmental conditions such as temperature. Discontinuous variation (such as eye color) is qualitative, controlled by one or a few major genes (monogenic inheritance), and produces distinct, non-overlapping categories that remain stable despite environmental fluctuations.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the phenotypic distribution pattern of wing length.
Wing length exhibits a smooth, quantitative spectrum of variation whose population mean shifts with ambient temperature.
Traits that exhibit a unbroken range of phenotypes and show environmental sensitivity are characteristic of continuous variation governed by polygenic inheritance.
2
Analyze the phenotypic distribution pattern of eye color.
Eye color falls into two distinct, non-overlapping qualitative classes in discrete ratios regardless of environmental temperature.
Traits with clear-cut, qualitative categories independent of environmental conditions represent discontinuous variation governed by monogenic inheritance.
3
Synthesize the findings to match genetic mechanisms with variation types.
Wing length is polygenic and environmentally modified, while eye color is monogenic and environmental resistant.
This correctly aligns the observed phenotypic patterns with their underlying genetic and environmental determinants.

Key Concept

Polygenic vs Monogenic Control in Continuous and Discontinuous Variation
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question