Examkin

Question

Difficulty: EasyLaw of Contract: Definition, Essential Elements, and Types

A business owner enters into a written agreement with a wholesaler to purchase commercial goods, while in a separate situation, a mother informally promises to pay her daughter a weekly allowance for doing household chores. Which of the following correctly describes the legal presumption regarding intention to create legal relations in these two arrangements?

  1. The commercial transaction is presumed to carry legal intention, whereas the domestic arrangement is presumed not to create legal relations.Answer
  2. B
    The domestic arrangement forms a binding specialty contract, whereas the commercial transaction is merely an invitation to treat.
  3. C
    Both arrangements are presumed to be legally binding contracts because an offer was made and accepted in both cases.
  4. D
    Neither arrangement is legally enforceable because informal promises always invalidate commercial contracts.

Answer

The commercial transaction is presumed to carry legal intention, whereas the domestic arrangement is presumed not to create legal relations.
Under the law of contract, intention to create legal relations is a fundamental element. Commercial transactions carry a legal presumption that parties intend to create legally binding obligations. In contrast, domestic and social agreements between family members carry the rebuttable presumption that the parties do not intend to enter into a legal contract.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the essential element of contract being tested
The core concept is 'Intention to Create Legal Relations', one of the essential elements of a valid contract.
For an agreement to be legally enforceable, the law requires that parties intend for legal consequences to attach to their agreement.
2
Apply legal presumptions to commercial vs domestic contexts
Commercial agreements are presumed in law to be legally binding, while domestic/family agreements are presumed not intended to be legally binding unless clear evidence indicates otherwise.
Courts avoid interfering in family life unless explicitly intended, but enforce trade relations to uphold commercial trust and stability.

Key Concept

Intention to Create Legal Relations (Commercial vs. Domestic Agreements)
Rate this question

Topics

Law of Contract: Definition, Essential Elements, and Types

More questions from this topic