Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardBasic Principles of Insurance

A logistics firm's delivery van valued at ₦12,000,000 was damaged in a road collision caused by a third party's negligence, resulting in ₦4,000,000 worth of structural damage. The insurance company fully indemnified the logistics firm for the ₦4,000,000 loss. When the logistics firm subsequently attempted to sue the negligent third party to recover another ₦4,000,000 for the exact same damage, the court dismissed the firm's suit. Which basic principle of insurance legally empowers the insurer to step into the shoes of the insured and assume their rights of recovery against negligent third parties?

  1. SubrogationAnswer
  2. B
    Contribution
  3. C
    Utmost Good Faith
  4. D
    Insurable Interest

Answer

Subrogation is the principle of insurance that legally transfers the rights of recovery against a negligent third party from the insured to the insurer after full compensation has been paid.
Subrogation is a direct corollary of the principle of indemnity. Once an insurer compensates the insured for a loss, the insurer assumes all legal rights and remedies that the insured possessed against the party responsible for the damage. This prevents double recovery by the insured while ensuring the negligent third party remains accountable.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the legal scenario and the relationship between the three parties (insured, insurer, third-party tortfeasor).
The insured suffered a loss of ₦4,000,000 caused by a negligent third party and received full financial restitution (indemnity) from their insurer.
Establishing that full indemnity has taken place is essential before subrogation rights can take effect.
2
Evaluate why the insured cannot collect another ₦4,000,000 from the negligent driver.
Allowing double recovery would violate the fundamental doctrine of indemnity by enabling the insured to make a profit from an insurance claim.
Insurance contracts of indemnity aim strictly to restore the policyholder to their pre-loss financial position.
3
Identify the specific legal mechanism that transfers legal recourse to the insurer.
Subrogation allows the insurer to step into the insured's legal standing to sue the negligent party and recover the paid out claim.
Subrogation acts as a direct corollary of indemnity to ensure tortfeasors remain held accountable without rewarding policyholders with double compensation.

Key Concept

Principle of Subrogation in Insurance
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Basic Principles of Insurance

More questions from this topic