Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardThe Welsh Government and Senedd Cymru

Senedd Cymru (the Welsh Parliament) and the Welsh Government are the two primary bodies of the devolved administration in Wales. Within the constitutional framework of the United Kingdom, which of the following statements accurately characterizes the relationship between these two bodies and the specific scope of their devolved authority?

  1. Senedd Cymru acts as the legislative body that passes laws and scrutinizes policy, while the Welsh Government is the executive branch; notably, unlike in Scotland, the power over the police and justice system remains reserved to the UK Parliament.Answer
  2. B
    The Welsh Government is the legislative body consisting of 60 members who meet to debate and pass Acts, while Senedd Cymru is the executive branch led by the First Minister with the authority to manage reserved matters such as national defense.
  3. C
    Senedd Cymru is the law-making body made up of 129 members elected every four years, and the Welsh Government is the executive branch which has full devolved authority over all civil and criminal justice matters in Wales.
  4. D
    The Welsh Government is the executive body responsible for creating new legislation, while Senedd Cymru is the administrative arm that implements these laws, including those relating to strictly reserved areas like immigration and social security.

Answer

Senedd Cymru is the legislative body that passes laws and scrutinizes policy, while the Welsh Government is the executive branch; notably, unlike in Scotland, the power over the police and justice system remains reserved to the UK Parliament.
The correct statement accurately identifies Senedd Cymru as the legislature (responsible for passing 'Acts of the Senedd') and the Welsh Government as the executive (responsible for day-to-day administration). It also correctly notes that the justice system is a reserved power for Wales, which is a significant constitutional difference between Welsh and Scottish devolution.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Distinguish between the legislative and executive branches of the Welsh devolved administration.
Senedd Cymru (the Welsh Parliament) is the legislature (makes laws), and the Welsh Government is the executive (implements policy).
Understanding the separation of powers is fundamental to identifying the correct roles of these institutions.
2
Verify the membership and election frequency according to official standards.
Senedd Cymru has 60 members (MSs).
This differentiates the Welsh Senedd from the Scottish Parliament, which has 129 members.
3
Analyze the specific powers devolved to Wales compared to other nations.
While health and education are devolved, the justice system and policing are 'reserved' powers in Wales (unlike in Scotland where they are devolved).
This high-level distinction is a key point of testing in complex devolution questions.

Key Concept

The separation of legislative and executive powers in Wales and the specific limits of Welsh devolution compared to Scotland.

Practice More

Review the specific list of reserved powers in the 'Life in the UK' handbook to ensure you can distinguish between Welsh, Scottish, and Northern Irish devolved authorities.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

The Welsh Government and Senedd Cymru

More questions from this topic