Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardThe 1990s: Good Friday Agreement and Devolution

In the late 1990s, the United Kingdom underwent a process of 'devolution' to redistribute political power. Which of the following accurately distinguishes the initial legislative authority and fiscal powers granted to the devolved bodies in Scotland and Wales when they began their work in 1999?

  1. The Scottish Parliament was established with the power to pass primary legislation and vary income tax, whereas the National Assembly for Wales initially held only secondary legislative powers and no tax-varying authority.Answer
  2. B
    The National Assembly for Wales was the only body in 1999 authorized to pass primary legislation independently of the UK Parliament, while the Scottish Parliament was restricted to implementing secondary regulations.
  3. C
    All three devolved administrations—the Scottish Parliament, the National Assembly for Wales, and the Northern Ireland Assembly—were granted identical primary legislative and fiscal powers in 1999 to ensure constitutional parity.
  4. D
    The 1998 Good Friday Agreement granted the Northern Ireland Assembly the right to vary the basic rate of income tax, a power that was withheld from both the Scottish Parliament and the Welsh Assembly until the 21st century.

Answer

The Scottish Parliament was granted primary legislative powers and the ability to vary income tax, while the National Assembly for Wales was initially limited to secondary legislation and had no fiscal powers.
The correct answer accurately identifies that the Scottish Parliament received more robust powers (primary legislation and tax variation) compared to the National Assembly for Wales, which was initially restricted to secondary legislation and had no fiscal autonomy.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the legislative status of the Scottish Parliament in 1999.
Under the Scotland Act 1998, it was granted 'primary' legislative powers (making new laws) and the 'Scottish Variable Rate' (varying income tax by up to 3%3\%).
Scotland's devolution model was the most extensive of the three nations initially.
2
Identify the legislative status of the National Assembly for Wales in 1999.
Under the Government of Wales Act 1998, it was granted 'secondary' powers (implementing/adjusting laws made at Westminster) and no tax powers.
The Welsh model was more limited, focusing on executive and secondary legislative functions.
3
Compare the two models to identify the distinction.
Scotland had both primary legislation and tax-varying powers; Wales had neither in 1999.
This 'asymmetric' devolution is a key feature of the UK's constitutional reform in the late 1990s.

Key Concept

Asymmetric Devolution
Rate this question

Topics

The 1990s: Good Friday Agreement and Devolution

More questions from this topic