Question

Difficulty: MediumFunction of Detail in Context

Read the following passage concerning the discovery of argon:

In 1892, Lord Rayleigh observed a persistent discrepancy in the density of nitrogen gas depending on its provenance: nitrogen isolated from atmospheric air was consistently approximately 0.5 percent denser than nitrogen synthesized through the chemical decomposition of compounds such as ammonium nitrite. While some contemporary physicists posited that atmospheric nitrogen might contain allotropic triatomic nitrogen (N3N_3) molecules analogous to ozone, William Ramsay collaborated with Rayleigh to investigate whether the anomaly pointed to an uncharacterized, heavier atmospheric constituent. To evaluate this, they revisited Henry Cavendish's 1785 spark-discharge experiments, in which Cavendish had noted that after repeatedly sparking air with excess oxygen and absorbing the resulting nitrogen oxides, an unreactive gas bubble comprising roughly 1/120th of the initial volume remained unabsorbed. Replicating and scaling this selective removal of known reactive components, Rayleigh and Ramsay successfully isolated a dense, chemically inert gas. Subsequent acoustic measurements of the gas's specific heat ratio (Cp/Cv≈1.66C_p/C_v \approx 1.66) demonstrated that its particles possessed only translational degrees of freedom, definitively proving the gas—named argon—to be monatomic rather than polyatomic.

Match each cited detail from the passage with the primary rhetorical function it serves in the author's account.

  • nitrogen synthesized through the chemical decomposition of compounds such as ammonium nitriteServing as a standardized baseline control against which the anomalous mass of atmospheric samples was identified
  • allotropic triatomic nitrogen (N3N_3) molecules analogous to ozoneRepresenting a competing hypothesis regarding the anomaly's source that required evaluation
  • Cavendish's 1785 spark-discharge experimentsIdentifying an earlier empirical observation that foreshadowed the existence of an unreactive fraction
  • acoustic measurements of the gas's specific heat ratio (Cp/Cv≈1.66C_p/C_v \approx 1.66)Supplying physical evidence that conclusively determined the single-atom structure of the isolated substance

Answer

Each cited detail correctly corresponds to its rhetorical role in the experimental narrative: chemical synthesis served as the comparison baseline; triatomic nitrogen represented an alternative explanatory hypothesis; Cavendish's work provided historical precedent; and the specific heat ratio supplied structural proof of monatomic state.
Each pair correctly matches the specific evidence cited in the passage to its rhetorical function in developing the discovery narrative: establishing an experimental baseline, identifying a competing hypothesis, citing an empirical historical precursor, and providing definitive structural proof.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the structural role of the chemical synthesis baseline in the first sentence.
The reference to chemically synthesized nitrogen from ammonium nitrite establishes the expected standard value, functioning as the baseline control against which the heavier atmospheric sample was contrasted.
Identifying the baseline allows the reader to understand how the empirical anomaly was initially detected.
2
Determine why the author mentions triatomic nitrogen and Cavendish's spark-discharge experiments in the middle of the passage.
Triatomic nitrogen represents an alternative competing explanation posited by other physicists, while Cavendish's experiment provides historical empirical precedence indicating the presence of an inert fraction.
Rhetorical analysis requires distinguishing between a counter-explanation and supporting historical context.
3
Evaluate the function of the specific heat ratio measurement at the conclusion of the passage.
The acoustic measurement of the specific heat ratio is introduced as conclusive physical evidence confirming the monatomic structure of argon.
The concluding detail provides final characterization and proof resolving the nature of the newly discovered element.

Key Concept

Function of Detail in Context
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question