Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardPoint at Issue and Point of Agreement

Mayor: To revitalize the deteriorating downtown commercial district, the city must grant substantial property tax abatements to large multinational retail chains. Only these corporations possess the capital required to rapidly renovate the district's abandoned storefronts. While they will dominate initially, the improved physical infrastructure and resulting surge in foot traffic will inevitably attract and sustain a vibrant community of local independent businesses shortly thereafter.

Urbanist: It is undeniable that multinational chains have the capital to quickly renovate the storefronts, and their presence would indeed generate a significant surge in foot traffic. However, granting them tax abatements will backfire. The influx of these heavily subsidized chains will artificially inflate commercial property values across the entire district, driving lease rates to exorbitant levels that will preclude any local independent businesses from operating there.

Based on the dialogue above, which of the following most accurately expresses the point of disagreement between the Mayor and the Urbanist?

  1. A
    Whether the presence of large multinational retail chains in the downtown district would successfully generate a significant increase in pedestrian foot traffic.
  2. B
    Whether the financial benefits independent businesses gain from increased foot traffic would be substantial enough to offset exorbitant commercial lease rates.
  3. Whether the execution of the proposed tax policy will ultimately facilitate the establishment of local independent businesses within the downtown district.Answer
  4. D
    Whether local independent businesses will be completely eliminated from the city's broader economy if the tax abatements are enacted.
  5. E
    Whether attracting a vibrant community of local independent businesses to the downtown district is guaranteed to result in the rapid renovation of its abandoned storefronts.

Answer

The correct answer is the option stating that the point of disagreement is whether the execution of the proposed tax policy will ultimately facilitate the establishment of local independent businesses within the downtown district.
The correct answer perfectly passes the two-speaker test. The Mayor explicitly claims that enacting the tax abatements for multinational chains will 'inevitably attract and sustain a vibrant community of local independent businesses.' The Urbanist directly contradicts this outcome, arguing that the same policy will 'preclude any local independent businesses from operating there.' One speaker definitively asserts the outcome, while the other definitively denies it.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the Mayor's primary argument and conclusion.
The Mayor argues that granting tax abatements to multinational chains will lead to rapid renovations and increased foot traffic, which will 'inevitably attract and sustain a vibrant community of local independent businesses.'
Understanding the first speaker's complete logical chain is necessary to find potential points of conflict.
2
Analyze the Urbanist's response to identify concessions and rebuttals.
The Urbanist concedes that the chains will renovate storefronts and increase foot traffic. However, the Urbanist concludes that inflated property values will drive up lease rates, which will 'preclude any local independent businesses from operating there.'
Separating points of agreement from points of contention narrows down the exact nature of the dispute.
3
Apply the two-speaker test to the core conflict.
Ask: 'Will the proposed tax abatements lead to local independent businesses establishing themselves in the downtown district?' The Mayor says 'Yes' (it will inevitably attract them). The Urbanist says 'No' (it will preclude them from operating there).
A valid point at issue must be a statement to which one speaker definitively assents and the other definitively dissents.

Key Concept

Identifying the Point of Disagreement using the Two-Speaker Test
Rate this question

Topics

Point at Issue and Point of Agreement

More questions from this topic