Question

Difficulty: MediumFunction of Specific Details

In the latter half of the nineteenth century, the rapid expansion of telegraphic networks fundamentally altered the pace of financial and journalistic communications. Paradoxically, however, this proliferation of electronic transmission created a severe logistical bottleneck within major urban centers. While instantaneous communication between distant cities was readily achieved, the final local distribution of received messages still relied heavily on fleets of messenger boys navigating increasingly congested city streets. To circumvent this inefficiency, engineers in metropolises such as London and Paris deployed extensive pneumatic tube networks—subterranean systems utilizing pressurized air to propel cylindrical canisters containing telegrams directly from central receiving offices to stock exchanges and major newspaper bureaus. Thus, although frequently dismissed by contemporary historians of technology as a quaint evolutionary dead-end, the pneumatic tube was a vital infrastructure that reconciled the electronic speed of the broader network with the physical constraints of urban delivery.

Which of the following best describes the primary rhetorical function of the author's reference to "fleets of messenger boys navigating increasingly congested city streets"?

  1. A
    characterize the physical distribution of telegrams as a quaint evolutionary dead-end in the lineage of telecommunications
  2. B
    contrast the instantaneous speed of intercity electronic transmission with the comparative sluggishness of local human labor
  3. delineate a specific logistical bottleneck that prompted the deployment of a novel infrastructural solutionAnswer
  4. D
    assert that contemporary historians of technology view early urban messenger systems as an inefficient logistical failure
  5. E
    describe the primary mode of transportation utilized by urban workers in the late nineteenth century

Answer

The correct answer identifies that the reference to messenger boys serves to delineate a specific logistical bottleneck that prompted the deployment of a novel infrastructural solution.
The correct answer accurately captures the structural role of the phrase within the passage. The author introduces the messenger boys as the embodiment of a 'logistical bottleneck' and an 'inefficiency' that engineers subsequently sought to 'circumvent' by deploying pneumatic tube networks. Therefore, the primary function of this detail is to illustrate the specific problem that necessitated the new infrastructure.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the context immediately surrounding the cited phrase.
The phrase appears just after the author notes a 'severe logistical bottleneck' and immediately before stating that engineers deployed pneumatic tubes 'to circumvent this inefficiency.'
Understanding the structural relationship between sentences is key to determining rhetorical function.
2
Identify the logical relationship between the phrase and the broader argument.
The messenger boys represent the 'inefficiency' or problem that the pneumatic tubes (the solution) were created to bypass.
The question asks for the primary function of the specific detail within the passage's overall framework.
3
Evaluate the options against this identified function.
The option stating the phrase delineates a logistical bottleneck that prompted a new infrastructural solution perfectly captures this problem-solution dynamic.
This matches the passage's logical flow where the cited detail necessitates the invention discussed in the subsequent sentences.

Key Concept

Identifying the primary rhetorical purpose of a specific detail within a passage's logical structure.
Rate this question