For decades, archaeological models of Mesopotamian administration attributed the origin of proto-cuneiform writing in late fourth-millennium BCE Uruk directly to the use of geometric clay tokens encased in spherical clay envelopes (*bullae*). According to this classical hypothesis, three-dimensional tokens represented specific commodities and quantities. When transactions occurred, tokens were sealed inside a clay bulla to prevent tampering; however, because the contents could not be verified without breaking the sealed sphere, accountants began pressing tokens onto the damp exterior surface before enclosing them, creating two-dimensional impressions. Eventually, administrators realized the hollow sphere and enclosed tokens were redundant, leading directly to flat clay tablets bearing impressed numerical signs and inscribed pictographs.
Recent excavations and stratigraphic re-evaluations at sites outside southern Mesopotamia, however, have complicated this unilinear model. Impressed flat tablets have been identified in archaeological horizons contemporaneous with, and in several instances predating, the widespread use of sealed *bullae* bearing exterior impressions. Furthermore, while plain geometric tokens (such as spheres, cones, and disks) appear across vast regions spanning several millennia with notable morphological stability, complex tokens bearing incised linear markings and punctations are largely confined to major monumental urban centers and appear concurrently with early tablet writing rather than preceding it. These chronological and spatial patterns suggest that rather than representing a sequential ancestral precursor to writing, complex tokens and flat tablets may have developed as parallel, specialized administrative responses to distinct logistical demands within increasingly stratified economies.
Based on the passage, which of the following statements regarding the relationship between *bullae* and early flat tablets is most strongly supported?
- The practice of creating two-dimensional surface impressions did not necessarily originate as an intermediate verification step for sealed clay envelopes.Answer
- BAccountants abandoned the use of hollow clay spheres because flat tablets proved far more durable when stored in central monumental archives.
- CThe transition to flat clay tablets completely eliminated the administrative need for tracking basic agricultural commodities with plain geometric tokens.
- DPlain geometric tokens were invented in major monumental urban centers specifically to manage the logistical complexities of stratified economies.
- EExternal impressions on clay bullae were utilized exclusively in regions outside southern Mesopotamia where flat tablets were unknown.