Question

Difficulty: EasyApplication to Analogous Situations

In the study of corporate strategy, analysts often focus on the benefits of being a pioneer in a new market, but they frequently overlook what economists term the 'second-mover advantage.' This phenomenon occurs when a pioneering company invests heavily in researching and developing a novel, untested infrastructure, absorbing all the financial risks and the costs of early failures. A second company can then enter the same market after the pioneer has successfully established a viable model. This second firm avoids the initial research and development expenses, bypasses the costly trial-and-error phase, and simply replicates the pioneer's proven infrastructure at a fraction of the cost, thereby gaining a competitive edge.

Which one of the following scenarios is most logically analogous to the 'second-mover advantage' as described in the passage?

  1. A research hospital spends millions of dollars and several years developing a highly effective surgical technique through trial and error, after which a competing clinic simply adopts the perfected technique by reading the published results.Answer
  2. B
    A pioneering company invests heavily in a novel infrastructure but fails because the market is not yet ready for the product, forcing the company into bankruptcy before competitors can arrive.
  3. C
    An established firm leverages its vast financial resources to aggressively market an existing product, successfully driving out the smaller competitors who originally invented the item.
  4. D
    A large technology corporation observes a small startup gaining popularity and decides to aggressively acquire the startup in order to gain exclusive ownership of its patents.
  5. E
    A retail chain delays opening its new location until a competitor proves the neighborhood is popular, but then discovers that the competitor has already captured all the available customer demand.

Answer

The scenario where a research hospital spends millions to develop a technique and a competing clinic simply adopts the perfected technique from published results.
The correct answer accurately strips away the business context and preserves the exact logical dynamic described in the passage: Entity 1 does the hard, expensive work of trial-and-error innovation, and Entity 2 swoops in to copy the final, successful product at little to no cost, thereby enjoying the benefits without the initial risks.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the core logic of the target concept in the passage.
The 'second-mover advantage' requires three elements: 1) A pioneer incurs high costs/risks to innovate. 2) A second actor waits. 3) The second actor replicates the proven model cheaply, gaining an advantage.
To identify an analogous situation, we must extract the abstract logical framework rather than focusing on the surface topic of corporate strategy.
2
Evaluate the options against the extracted logical framework.
The correct option features a research hospital (pioneer) bearing the high cost/risk, and a competing clinic (second actor) adopting the successful technique for free, perfectly matching the framework.
The correct answer must share the underlying abstract relationship with the passage's phenomenon.

Key Concept

Identifying analogous relationships by mapping the core logical structure (a pioneer bearing the costs of innovation while a later actor adopts the proven model for free) to a new scenario.
Rate this question