Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardInferences from the Text

The decipherment of Linear B in 1952 established it as an early form of Greek, revolutionizing the understanding of Mycenaean civilization. However, its predecessor, Linear A, used by the Minoans on Crete, remains undeciphered. Despite this linguistic barrier, archaeologists have inferred significant continuity in administrative practices between the Minoan and Mycenaean palatial systems by analyzing the structural formatting of the tablets. In both scripts, ideograms representing commodities (such as grain, livestock, and oil) are combined with numeral signs in remarkably similar ledger formats.

Some scholars argue that the Mycenaeans wholesale appropriated the Minoan administrative apparatus when they conquered Crete. However, this narrative obscures a subtle but crucial divergence. While Linear A tablets frequently feature fractional signs indicating a complex system of exact proportional allocation, Linear B tablets overwhelmingly rely on standardized whole-unit quotas, with deficits recorded as distinct entries rather than fractional allocations. This shift suggests that while the Mycenaeans adopted the mechanism of Minoan record-keeping, their underlying economic philosophy was fundamentally different: transitioning from a highly localized, precise redistributive model to a more centralized, rigid tributary system that prioritized administrative predictability over exact economic reflection.

Based on the passage, which of the following statements can be most strongly inferred regarding the Minoan and Mycenaean administrative systems? (Select all that apply)

  1. The ability to compare the administrative practices of the Minoan and Mycenaean palatial systems does not depend entirely on the phonetic decipherment of their respective scripts.Answer
  2. B
    The Mycenaean economic philosophy, unlike that of the Minoans, necessitated a ledger format capable of recording exact proportional allocations of commodities.
  3. A Mycenaean record-keeper tracking a grain deficit would be less likely to use a fractional symbol than a Minoan record-keeper would be when allocating a partial grain quota.Answer
  4. D
    The Mycenaeans' appropriation of the Minoan administrative apparatus included the adoption of both the structural formatting of the ledgers and the precise redistributive model of the Minoan economy.
  5. E
    The undeciphered status of Linear A prevents contemporary archaeologists from drawing reliable conclusions about the specific types of commodities the Minoans distributed.

Answer

The correct statements are that comparing administrative practices does not depend entirely on phonetic decipherment, and that a Mycenaean record-keeper tracking a deficit would be less likely to use a fractional symbol than a Minoan record-keeper allocating a partial quota.
The correct options logically synthesize the passage's explicit statements. First, the text notes that archaeologists have inferred continuity by analyzing structural formatting and ideograms 'despite this linguistic barrier' of Linear A being undeciphered, proving that phonetic decipherment isn't entirely necessary for comparative analysis. Second, the text directly contrasts the Minoan (Linear A) use of fractional signs for exact proportional allocation with the Mycenaean (Linear B) reliance on whole-unit quotas that record deficits as distinct entries rather than using fractions.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the relationship between scripts, civilizations, and economic models presented in the text.
Linear A corresponds to the Minoans (undeciphered, uses fractional signs, exact proportional allocation, precise redistributive model). Linear B corresponds to the Mycenaeans (deciphered, uses whole-unit quotas, deficits as distinct entries, centralized tributary system).
Mapping the specific attributes to the correct civilization is critical for evaluating comparative statements.
2
Evaluate the inference regarding script decipherment.
The text states archaeologists infer continuity by 'analyzing the structural formatting' and 'ideograms' despite Linear A remaining undeciphered. This logically supports the inference that phonetic decipherment is not strictly required for such administrative comparisons.
Direct synthesis of the first paragraph's premises.
3
Evaluate the inference regarding the specific behavior of record-keepers.
The text explicitly contrasts Minoan fractional signs with Mycenaean whole-unit quotas where deficits are distinct entries rather than fractions. This strongly supports the behavioral inference about how each record-keeper would document partial amounts or shortfalls.
Applying the abstract rules of the two ledger systems described in the text to a concrete, parallel hypothetical scenario.

Key Concept

Inferences from the Text
Rate this question

Topics

Inferences from the Text

More questions from this topic