Question

Difficulty: MediumInferences from the Text

In 1899, botanist Clement Reid identified an apparent anomaly in post-glacial vegetation history: the documented northward expansion of heavy-seeded deciduous trees across Europe following the Last Glacial Maximum occurred far more rapidly than could be explained by observed dispersal mechanisms, such as local wind distribution and standard animal foraging. If these species had been confined entirely to southern Mediterranean refugia during the glacial peak, their migration to northern Europe would have required tens of thousands of years longer than the fossil pollen record reveals. To resolve "Reid's paradox," paleoecologists hypothesized both rare long-distance dispersal events by corvid birds and the existence of cryptic northern microrefugia—small, climatically buffered valleys where isolated tree populations persisted at higher latitudes. While conventional macrofossil evidence for such northern populations was long elusive, recent analyses of sedimentary ancient DNA preserved in lake beds have confirmed the presence of localized tree stands well north of the Mediterranean belt during the height of the glaciation. Consequently, the actual distances that recolonizing forests had to traverse were significantly shorter than traditional biogeographical models assumed, easing the theoretical burden placed on extreme seed-dispersal mechanisms.

Based on the passage, which of the following assertions are logically supported? (Select all that apply.)

  1. Traditional biogeographical models of post-glacial forest recolonization overestimated the geographical distance that certain deciduous tree populations needed to traverse after the Last Glacial Maximum.Answer
  2. B
    Sedimentary ancient DNA has replaced fossil pollen records as the primary empirical standard for establishing the overall timeline of post-glacial plant migration.
  3. The absence of identifiable macrofossil remains in a region does not establish conclusively that tree populations were entirely absent from that area during a glacial period.Answer
  4. D
    Corvid birds were responsible for a larger total volume of post-glacial seed dispersal in Europe than any other animal group.
  5. E
    The rapid expansion of deciduous trees proved that local wind dispersal operates more rapidly across glaciated terrain than across densely forested landscapes.

Answer

The supported statements are that traditional models overestimated the migration distances required for post-glacial recolonization, and that the absence of macrofossil remains in a region does not definitively prove that tree populations were entirely absent during a glacial maximum.
The correct statements reflect direct logical deductions from the text. The statement regarding traditional models is directly supported by the author's conclusion that actual dispersal distances were significantly shorter than traditional biogeographical models assumed. The statement regarding macrofossil evidence is supported by the fact that tree stands were proven to exist via sedimentary DNA despite the long-standing absence of macrofossil traces.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the text for explicit premises regarding traditional models and migration distances
The final sentence demonstrates that because northern microrefugia preserved small tree populations, the actual distance required for expansion was shorter than traditional models had presumed.
This confirms that traditional models overestimated the required migration distance.
2
Evaluate the evidentiary relationship between macrofossils and population persistence
The text notes macrofossil evidence was elusive despite the confirmed survival of northern tree populations via ancient DNA.
This establishes that lack of macrofossil findings does not constitute proof of total absence.
3
Assess the remaining statements against the text to check for unsupported logical leaps or external assumptions
Claims regarding the replacement of pollen records, comparative corvid dominance, and wind speed over terrain types lack textual corroboration.
Eliminating unsupported options ensures only logically necessary or strongly supported deductions remain.

Key Concept

Drawing strictly supported inferences from scientific reading passages by synthesizing explicit textual premises and avoiding unwarranted extrapolations.
Rate this question