Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumVocabulary in Context

The architects of the early republic conceived of the federal judiciary not as a primary engine of social progress, but rather as an institutional check against the majoritarian impulses of the legislature. According to this originalist view, when courts abandon this negative function and instead actively fashion new rights based on an evolving moral consensus, they usurp the democratic process. Such judicial interventionism, however well-intentioned it may be in addressing immediate societal inequities, ultimately undermines the legitimacy of the courts; their authority rests entirely on the public's perception of their adherence to objective, pre-existing legal principles rather than their participation in partisan policy-making.

Which of the following phrases most accurately replaces the word "negative" as it is used in the passage?

  1. A
    characterized by pessimism regarding social progress
  2. B
    ultimately detrimental to the legitimacy of democratic processes
  3. C
    fundamentally adversarial and hostile to legislative impulses
  4. oriented toward restricting actions rather than proactively creating policyAnswer
  5. E
    devoid of substantive legal or constitutional authority

Answer

The correct answer is the phrase indicating an orientation toward restricting actions rather than proactively creating policy.
The correct answer accurately synthesizes the contextual clues surrounding the target word. The passage explicitly contrasts the target function with the active creation of new rights ('actively fashion new rights'), and directly links this function to the judiciary's role as an 'institutional check.' In constitutional and political theory, a function characterized in this way is one that limits or vetoes the actions of other branches rather than initiating or creating policy.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the target word in the text and analyze its immediate grammatical surroundings.
The word appears in the phrase 'abandon this negative function and instead actively fashion new rights'.
Direct contextual clues are the primary way to determine the specific intended meaning of a polysemous word.
2
Identify the contrast established by the author in that specific sentence.
The target function is directly contrasted with 'actively fashion[ing] new rights,' indicating that the function is about restricting or limiting rather than creating.
Authors frequently use contrasting phrases (like 'instead') to implicitly define specialized terminology.
3
Connect this working definition back to the preceding sentence to ensure it aligns with the broader argument.
The previous sentence describes the judiciary as an 'institutional check against the majoritarian impulses,' which confirms that its role is prohibitive or restrictive in nature.
Ensuring the working definition aligns with the passage's broader logic prevents selecting an answer that only fits a narrow fragment of the text.
4
Evaluate the answer choices to find the one that best matches this synthesized definition.
The option describing an orientation toward restricting actions perfectly matches the concept of an 'institutional check' and contrasts directly with 'actively fashion[ing] new rights.'
The correct choice must capture both the denotation and the specific rhetorical role the word plays in the author's argument.

Key Concept

Vocabulary in Context
Rate this question

Topics

Vocabulary in Context

More questions from this topic