Match each logically flawed argument on the left with the precise abstract description of its composition or division reasoning error on the right.
- Each individual synthetic thread woven into the newly designed climbing harness is exceptionally lightweight. Therefore, the completely assembled climbing harness must be exceptionally lightweight.Illicitly presumes that a physical object must possess a particular characteristic merely because all of the materials from which it is constructed possess that characteristic.
- The Global Trade Syndicate is the wealthiest and most influential commercial bloc in the international market. Since the nation of Oakhaven is a member of the Syndicate, Oakhaven must be one of the wealthiest nations in the market.Takes for granted that an attribute characterizing a unified organization must also uniquely characterize a specific member belonging to that organization.
- Every single piece of antique furniture being loaded into the moving van is relatively small and occupies very little space. Consequently, the entire collection of antique furniture will occupy very little space in the van.Infers that a collection of items as a whole has a particular quantitative property based solely on the fact that each individual item in the collection has that property.
- The recently released model of the Zephyr automobile has an overall aerodynamic drag coefficient that is lower than that of any other vehicle in its class. Thus, the Zephyr's windshield must have a lower drag coefficient than the windshields of other vehicles.Unreasonably concludes that a particular physical component of a complex machine possesses a certain quality simply because the machine as a whole possesses that quality.
Answer
The climbing harness argument matches the flaw of assuming an object shares the properties of its materials; the Syndicate argument matches the flaw of assuming a member shares the properties of its organization; the furniture argument matches the flaw of assuming a collection shares the quantitative properties of its individual items; and the Zephyr car argument matches the flaw of assuming a component shares the properties of the overall machine.
The correct matches accurately identify the distinct variations of composition and division flaws present in each stimulus. They rigorously distinguish between part-to-whole reasoning in physical objects versus collections, and whole-to-part reasoning in mechanical systems versus organizations.
Step-by-Step Solution
Key Concept
Distinguishing between nuanced variations of composition and division flaws, specifically separating physical part-to-whole reasoning from member-to-group and item-to-collection reasoning.
Estimated Time:2m 0s