Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardVocabulary in Context

Read the following passage excerpt:

"In assessing the jurisprudential legacy of Legal Realism, contemporary scholars frequently emphasize the movement's successful dismantling of formalist dogma, which had long posited that judicial decisions are derived through strict deductive reasoning from self-evident axioms. Yet, this celebratory consensus often obscures the profoundly *plastic* nature of the Realists' own prescriptive commitments. While the Realists were united in their empirical critique of how judges actually decide cases, their positive visions for legal and institutional reform ranged wildly—from advocating for technocratic administration driven by emerging social sciences, to demanding a radical democratization of the judiciary. Consequently, attempting to isolate a singular, coherent Realist agenda is less an exercise in historical recovery than an act of retrospective imposition."

The author's use of the word "plastic" to describe the Realists' prescriptive commitments serves primarily to indicate that these commitments were:

  1. A
    fundamentally artificial, lacking a genuine foundation in empirical legal observation
  2. B
    inherently adaptable, allowing them to be universally applied to future jurisprudential dilemmas
  3. highly malleable, encompassing drastically divergent approaches to institutional reformAnswer
  4. D
    largely superficial, serving to mask deep logical inconsistencies within the movement's positive visions
  5. E
    essentially synthetic, representing a unified historical narrative imposed by contemporary scholars

Answer

highly malleable, encompassing drastically divergent approaches to institutional reform
The correct answer accurately synthesizes the contextual definition of 'plastic' with the textual evidence that immediately follows it. In the passage, 'plastic' is used in its sense of being malleable, pliable, or capable of taking many forms. The sentence immediately following explains that the Realists' positive visions for reform 'ranged wildly' from technocratic administration to radical democratization. Therefore, their commitments were highly fluid and accommodated drastically divergent approaches to institutional reform.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the context immediately surrounding the target word 'plastic'.
The sentence states that the 'celebratory consensus' obscures the 'profoundly plastic nature' of the Realists' prescriptive commitments.
The meaning of a word in a Reading Comprehension passage is dictated by its specific context, not its most common colloquial definition.
2
Identify the subsequent textual evidence that defines or elaborates on this nature.
The very next sentence explains that these commitments 'ranged wildly' from 'technocratic administration' to 'radical democratization'.
Authors typically follow up complex, nuanced, or polysemous terms with examples or elaborations that clarify their intended meaning.
3
Synthesize the contextual clues to determine the precise meaning of the term.
The term 'plastic' in this context must mean capable of taking many forms, varied, or malleable, since it describes a set of beliefs that range between extreme opposites.
Matching the target word with structural evidence ensures accuracy and avoids relying on outside knowledge.
4
Evaluate the answer choices against this synthesized meaning.
The option describing the commitments as 'highly malleable, encompassing drastically divergent approaches' perfectly matches the synthesized meaning and textual evidence.
This actively eliminates distractors that rely on outside definitions (e.g., 'artificial') or conflate other parts of the passage.

Key Concept

Vocabulary in Context
Estimated Time:2m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Vocabulary in Context

More questions from this topic