Question

Difficulty: MediumFunction of Specific Details

For decades, archaeologists assumed that Linear B, an ancient script found on clay tablets in Crete and mainland Greece, recorded an unknown Minoan language. This assumption was largely based on the script's visual dissimilarity from the Greek alphabet and its association with the pre-Hellenic Minoan civilization. However, in 1952, Michael Ventris proposed that Linear B was actually an early form of Greek. Many scholars initially resisted this hypothesis. They pointed out that the script, a syllabary rather than an alphabet, seemed fundamentally unsuited for representing Greek phonology, which features complex consonant clusters that a syllabic system struggles to capture without ambiguity. Yet, Ventris's systematic application of a grid method eventually yielded recognizable Greek words, definitively proving his theory.

Which of the following best describes the primary function of the author's reference to "complex consonant clusters"?

  1. To explain the linguistic basis for scholars' initial resistance to Ventris's hypothesis.Answer
  2. B
    To contrast the phonetic structure of Linear B with the phonetic structure of the unknown Minoan language.
  3. C
    To express the author's own reservation regarding the suitability of the grid method for translating ancient texts.
  4. D
    To demonstrate why a syllabary is generally an inherently ambiguous writing system compared to an alphabet.
  5. E
    To provide an example of the specific types of recognizable Greek words that Ventris was able to decipher.

Answer

The correct answer is the option stating that the reference explains the linguistic basis for scholars' initial resistance to Ventris's hypothesis.
The correct option accurately captures the structural relationship in the passage. The author introduces Ventris's hypothesis, notes that scholars resisted it, and then uses the fact that Greek features 'complex consonant clusters' as the specific linguistic evidence those scholars cited to justify their skepticism.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the targeted phrase ('complex consonant clusters') in the passage.
The phrase is found in the sentence: 'They pointed out that the script... seemed fundamentally unsuited for representing Greek phonology, which features complex consonant clusters...'
Identifying the exact location provides the immediate context needed to determine rhetorical function.
2
Analyze the context surrounding the phrase to determine its argumentative purpose.
The preceding sentence states that 'Many scholars initially resisted this hypothesis.' The sentence containing the phrase begins with 'They pointed out...', indicating that the consonant clusters are the reason provided by the scholars for their resistance.
Understanding how sentences logically connect reveals the structural role of specific details.
3
Match the identified purpose with the answer choices.
The option describing the phrase as explaining the basis for scholars' initial resistance perfectly matches the analysis from Step 2.
This confirms the correct interpretation of the detail's meta-argumentative function.

Key Concept

Function of Specific Details
Rate this question