Question

Difficulty: EasySpecific Detail Inferences

During the Abbasid Caliphate, the Translation Movement (centered in Baghdad from the late eighth to the tenth century) was not merely a passive transmission of ancient Greek knowledge into the Arabic language. Rather, it was a dynamic and highly selective process driven by the immediate administrative, medical, and astrological needs of the rapidly growing Islamic empire. Translators did not aim to preserve Greek texts out of purely historical curiosity or a desire to absorb Hellenistic culture in its entirety. Instead, the focus was intensely practical and utilitarian. For instance, Greek medical treatises by physicians such as Galen and Hippocrates were translated primarily because the expanding urban centers of the Caliphate required a formally systematized medical profession to manage public health. Similarly, advanced astronomical texts were highly prized because they allowed administrators to accurately determine precise prayer times and maintain the lunar calendar, while also enabling court astrologers to make important political predictions. Conversely, Greek literature, such as the epic poetry of Homer or the dramatic tragedies of Sophocles, was almost entirely ignored by translators during this period. The mythological and polytheistic elements inherent in Greek poetry held little practical value for Abbasid scholars and explicitly conflicted with established Islamic theological frameworks. Consequently, the surviving Arabic manuscripts from this era represent a heavily filtered intellectual heritage, one that prized tangible utility and applied sciences over literary exploration or historical antiquarianism.

Based on the passage, which of the following can be most reasonably inferred about the works of Homer and Sophocles?

  1. Their absence from the corpus of translated works was due in part to their lack of alignment with the practical priorities of the Caliphate.Answer
  2. B
    They were highly prized because they contained mythological elements that allowed astrologers to make accurate political predictions.
  3. C
    They were eventually translated during the tenth century once the Caliphate's immediate need for medical and astronomical texts had been fully satisfied.
  4. D
    They were utilized by Abbasid administrators specifically to assist in organizing the rapidly expanding urban centers.
  5. E
    They were systematically and entirely destroyed by Abbasid scholars because their polytheistic elements posed a direct threat to the empire.

Answer

Their absence from the corpus of translated works was due in part to their lack of alignment with the practical priorities of the Caliphate.
The correct answer accurately synthesizes the passage's statements that the translation movement was driven by utilitarian needs and that Greek literature was ignored precisely because its mythological elements 'held little practical value'.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the question stem
The question asks for a reasonable inference regarding the works of Homer and Sophocles based on the provided text.
Understanding the specific target of the inference ensures that we focus on the relevant section of the passage.
2
Locate the relevant information in the passage
The passage states that the epic poetry of Homer and tragedies of Sophocles were 'almost entirely ignored' because their mythological and polytheistic elements 'held little practical value' and conflicted with Islamic frameworks.
Finding the specific sentences discussing Homer and Sophocles is necessary to determine what is factually supported.
3
Evaluate the correct option against the located text
The correct option states that the absence of these works was due to a lack of alignment with practical priorities. This perfectly matches the text's assertion that they were ignored for holding 'little practical value'.
This confirms that the inference is a valid, logical deduction directly grounded in the passage's explicit details.

Key Concept

Identifying specific detail inferences requires connecting explicitly stated facts about a subject to logically unavoidable conclusions without overstating the text.
Rate this question