Question

Difficulty: HardDistinguishing Main Point from Subsidiary Points

Read the following passage regarding the history of intellectual property law. Then, match each excerpted statement from the passage to its rhetorical role in the author's argument.

Passage:
Recent scholarship on the history of copyright law has increasingly challenged the traditional view that intellectual property regimes were primarily designed to incentivize individual creative genius. While it is undeniable that the Statute of Anne (1710) formally recognized authors' rights for the first time, this legislative landmark was less a triumph of authors' advocacy than a pragmatic compromise brokered by powerful publishing guilds seeking to reestablish their monopoly over the book trade. Indeed, the narrative of the 'romantic author' was largely a retroactive justification, popularized in the nineteenth century, to mask the fundamentally commercial origins of copyright. Therefore, we must reconceptualize early copyright law not as a noble mechanism for rewarding creativity, but rather as an instrument of market regulation designed to protect entrenched economic interests.

  • "Recent scholarship on the history of copyright law has increasingly challenged the traditional view..."Background Context
  • "While it is undeniable that the Statute of Anne (1710) formally recognized authors' rights..."Concessive Counter-premise
  • "Indeed, the narrative of the 'romantic author' was largely a retroactive justification..."Subsidiary Evidence
  • "Therefore, we must reconceptualize early copyright law... as an instrument of market regulation..."Central Thesis

Answer

The correct pairings align each excerpt with its structural function: the introductory sentence serves as Background Context, the concession about the Statute of Anne acts as a Concessive Counter-premise, the claim regarding the 'romantic author' serves as Subsidiary Evidence, and the final synthesis represents the Central Thesis.
The correct pairings accurately reflect the logical structure of an LSAT passage. The author begins by framing the scholarly debate (Background Context), then concedes a point to the opposing view (Concessive Counter-premise) before delivering historical proof (Subsidiary Evidence) that builds to the ultimate conclusion regarding copyright's true commercial nature (Central Thesis).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the overarching argument of the passage.
The author argues that early copyright law was driven by commercial interests and market regulation rather than the desire to reward individual creativity.
Identifying the main point is necessary to determine the rhetorical function of all other sentences, which either support, contextualize, or contrast with this main point.
2
Evaluate the role of the introductory sentence.
This sentence introduces the academic debate and the traditional view that the author will argue against, functioning as Background Context.
It frames the discussion but does not state the author's definitive conclusion.
3
Analyze the function of the statement beginning 'While it is undeniable...'
This clause acknowledges a historical fact (the Statute of Anne recognizing authors' rights) that seems to support the traditional view, acting as a Concessive Counter-premise.
Authors use concessions to acknowledge opposing evidence before recontextualizing or refuting it.
4
Determine the role of the claim about the 'romantic author' narrative.
This statement provides specific historical analysis to substantiate the author's claim that copyright's origins were commercial, serving as Subsidiary Evidence.
It is a supporting premise used to build the case for the final conclusion.
5
Assess the final sentence beginning with 'Therefore...'
This sentence synthesizes the argument into the central claim that copyright was an instrument of market regulation, representing the Central Thesis.
It is the ultimate conclusion that all preceding evidence and context were leading up to.

Key Concept

Distinguishing Main Point from Subsidiary Points
Rate this question