Question

Difficulty: MediumInferences from the Text

Unlike volcanically driven hydrothermal systems along mid-ocean ridge axes, which are characterized by acidic, black-smoker fluids reaching temperatures in excess of 350°C, hydrothermal systems situated on mantle peridotite detachments—such as the off-axis Lost City field—are powered by the serpentinization reaction. In this process, seawater circulating through exposed mantle peridotite reacts exothermically with the magnesium- and iron-rich mineral olivine at moderate temperatures (100°C–250°C). This low-temperature hydration oxidizes ferrous iron (Fe2+Fe^{2+}) to ferric iron (Fe3+Fe^{3+}), precipitating magnetite and releasing large quantities of molecular hydrogen (H2H_2). This abundant dissolved H2H_2 drives the hyperalkaline pH (9 to 11) of the emergent fluids and reduces dissolved inorganic carbon through Fischer-Tropsch–type reactions, generating abiotic methane (CH4CH_4) and short-chain alkanes without biological mediation. Because these ultramafic systems do not rely on magmatic heat sources, their vent chimneys are composed not of polymetallic sulfides, but of calcium carbonate and magnesium hydroxide minerals precipitated when high-pH, calcium-rich hydrothermal fluids mix with cold, carbonate-rich deep ocean water. Moreover, radiometric dating of these carbonate structures demonstrates that serpentinization-driven fields can remain continuously active for tens of thousands of years—more than two orders of magnitude longer than individual magmatic black-smoker vents, which are routinely extinguished when local magma chambers cool or migrate.

Based on the passage, which of the following statements regarding hydrothermal systems are logically supported? (Select all that apply.)

  1. Peridotite-hosted hydrothermal fields can maintain active fluid circulation even in regions devoid of immediate magmatic heat sources.Answer
  2. B
    The chemical reactions in black-smoker vent systems produce significantly higher concentrations of dissolved molecular hydrogen than serpentinization reactions produce.
  3. A chimney structure composed primarily of polymetallic sulfides is unlikely to have formed through low-temperature serpentinization of exposed mantle olivine.Answer
  4. D
    The abiotic hydrocarbons produced at alkaline hydrothermal vents served as the primary organic precursor molecules for the origin of terrestrial life on early Earth.
  5. E
    Individual magmatic black-smoker vents typically remain continuously active for hundreds of thousands of years before their magma supply migrates.

Answer

The statements indicating that peridotite-hosted systems can maintain circulation without immediate magmatic heat and that polymetallic sulfide chimneys are unlikely to form via low-temperature serpentinization are both logically entailed by the passage.
Both correct statements are directly grounded in the passage text: first, the passage explicitly asserts that serpentinization-driven hydrothermal fields do not rely on magmatic heat sources because the process is driven exothermically by olivine hydration; second, the passage contrasts the mineral composition of vent chimneys, attributing polymetallic sulfide deposits to volcanically driven black-smoker systems while establishing that serpentinization systems precipitate calcium carbonate and magnesium hydroxide.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the passage statements regarding heat source and driving mechanism for peridotite-hosted systems.
The text notes that serpentinization systems are exothermic and 'do not rely on magmatic heat sources,' validating the statement that fluid circulation can occur in the absence of immediate magmatism.
Direct textual deduction from the explicit description of the reaction mechanism.
2
Evaluate the passage claims about chimney mineralogy across vent classes.
The text explicitly states serpentinization chimneys are 'composed not of polymetallic sulfides, but of calcium carbonate and magnesium hydroxide minerals,' validating the inference that polymetallic sulfide chimneys are unlikely products of olivine serpentinization.
Synthesizing contrasting mineralogical descriptions between black smokers and peridotite vents.
3
Verify and eliminate distractors based on scope, quantification, and external information boundaries.
Discard the hydrogen comparison (unsupported claim), the origin-of-life hypothesis (outside knowledge), and the vent lifespan estimate (misread magnitude modifier).
Prevents logical fallacies and adherence to strict closed-universe text constraints.

Key Concept

Drawing Valid Necessary Inferences and Identifying Negative Inferences in Scientific Texts
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question