Question

Difficulty: EasyPrimary Purpose in Multi-Viewpoint Passages

Biologists have long debated the evolutionary function of play in young mammals. Traditionalists argue that play serves primarily as physical training, allowing animals to hone the motor skills necessary for hunting and survival. In contrast, a newer school of ethologists proposes the "cognitive flexibility" hypothesis, suggesting that the true evolutionary benefit of play is to prepare the developing brain to handle unexpected social and environmental situations. While the physical training hypothesis accounts for basic forms of play, the cognitive flexibility model offers a far more comprehensive explanation for the highly erratic and varied play behaviors observed across mammalian species.

Which one of the following most accurately describes the primary purpose of the passage?

  1. Evaluate two competing scientific models regarding animal play and argue that one is more comprehensive.Answer
  2. B
    Outline the specific motor skills that young mammals develop through physical play.
  3. C
    Summarize two differing scientific perspectives on play without taking a definitive stance on either.
  4. D
    Prove definitively that the traditional physical training hypothesis is completely invalid for all species.
  5. E
    Describe the evolutionary challenges and environmental situations that young mammals face in the wild.

Answer

Evaluate two competing scientific models regarding animal play and argue that one is more comprehensive.
The correct answer perfectly maps to the structural flow of the text: the author introduces two differing scientific views (physical training vs. cognitive flexibility) and then explicitly evaluates them, arguing in the final sentence that one model is 'far more comprehensive.'

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the distinct viewpoints presented in the passage.
The passage outlines the 'Traditionalists' (physical training hypothesis) and a 'newer school of ethologists' (cognitive flexibility hypothesis).
Recognizing the multiple perspectives is the first step in understanding a multi-viewpoint passage's structure.
2
Determine the author's stance regarding these viewpoints.
The author explicitly favors the newer perspective, stating that the cognitive flexibility model 'offers a far more comprehensive explanation.'
The author's stance dictates the ultimate rhetorical purpose (e.g., whether they are a neutral observer or an active participant evaluating the models).
3
Synthesize the viewpoints and the author's stance to define the primary purpose.
The passage's goal is to introduce both hypotheses and advocate for the superiority of the cognitive flexibility model.
The primary purpose must account for the entire structural arc of the text, not just a portion of it.

Key Concept

Primary Purpose in Multi-Viewpoint Passages
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question