**Passage:** In the mid-nineteenth century, urban planners in several major European citie… — LSAT

Passage:
In the mid-nineteenth century, urban planners in several major European cities embarked on massive redesign projects, ostensibly driven by the prevailing 'miasma' theory of disease, which posited that foul, stagnant air spread illness. By widening streets and constructing extensive sewer networks, planners claimed to be primarily motivated by public hygiene. However, municipal correspondence reveals that these sanitary justifications often provided convenient rhetorical cover for a different objective: political stabilization. The narrow, winding medieval streets that were demolished were precisely those that had facilitated working-class barricades during recent urban uprisings. By dispersing these dense neighborhoods and creating broad avenues that allowed for the rapid deployment of cavalry, the new urban layout structurally impeded rebellion. While these reforms ultimately yielded significant public health dividends, the architectural prioritization of crowd control over localized community sanitation suggests that planners were more concerned with inoculating the state against revolution than curing the populace of cholera.

Question:
Consider a modern urban renewal initiative in which city officials propose replacing dense, low-income housing with a sprawling, state-of-the-art 'eco-park,' publicly justifying the project entirely on the grounds of improving urban air quality and reducing the city's carbon footprint. Based on the passage, which of the following best describes how the author would most likely view the officials' public justification?

The author would likely approach the environmental justification with suspicion, considering the possibility that it serves as rhetorical cover for dispersing a specific socioeconomic group.Answer
B
The author would reject the justification entirely, predicting that the eco-park will yield absolutely no actual environmental benefits to the city.
C
The author would accept the justification as genuine, given that modern environmental science is objectively verifiable, unlike nineteenth-century miasma theory.
D
The author would conclude that the city officials are prioritizing public hygiene in order to create broad avenues that allow for the rapid deployment of cavalry.
E
The author would insist that whenever a city proposes a large-scale infrastructure project, its sole true objective is always the political stabilization of the state.

Answer

The correct answer is the option stating that the author would likely approach the environmental justification with suspicion, considering it might serve as rhetorical cover for dispersing a specific socioeconomic group.

The author demonstrates a pattern of looking past stated public welfare justifications (like hygiene) to uncover underlying political or social motives (like dispersing dense neighborhoods). Thus, the author would likely apply this same analytical skepticism to a modern project that uses a public welfare initiative (environmentalism) to justify the dispersal of low-income housing.

Step-by-Step Solution

Analyze the author's core argument and methodology in the passage.

The author demonstrates that past urban planners used a public welfare justification (public hygiene) to mask a political motive (dispersing working-class neighborhoods to prevent uprisings).

Understanding how the author interprets historical events is necessary to predict how they would interpret a new, parallel situation.

Examine the hypothetical modern scenario provided in the question stem.

The scenario involves city officials using a public welfare justification (environmentalism) to replace dense, low-income housing with an eco-park.

Identifying the parallels between the historical and modern scenarios allows for the application of the author's perspective.

Apply the author's analytical framework to the new scenario and evaluate the given options.

The author would likely view the modern environmental justification with the same skepticism applied to the historical hygiene justification, suspecting an underlying motive of social or political control.

This directly extrapolates the author's established viewpoint to the newly presented information, leading to the correct answer.

Key Concept

Extrapolating the author's analytical framework to a new, analogous situation.

Question

Answer

Step-by-Step Solution

Key Concept

Common Mistakes

Topics

More questions from this topic